‘I want to slap you around a bit, too’: Victorian magistrate reprimanded over language in court

A Victorian magistrate has been reprimanded after using offensive language during court proceedings, including a comment telling a court user, “I want to slap you around a bit, too.” The remark has drawn criticism for its inappropriate nature.

The comment was one of several made by magistrate Vicky Prapas that the state’s judicial watchdog found to be improper. Others included asking a court participant, “Do you reckon the substance is screwing with the way you’re thinking?” and stating that another person “believes their own bullshit.”

The latter remark was made in the presence of a school group, according to the Judicial Commission of Victoria’s recent findings.

The investigation was launched after Victoria Legal Aid filed a complaint concerning Prapas’ involvement in a Melbourne drug court. The watchdog substantiated multiple allegations, including claims that the magistrate made threatening or intimidating remarks to legal practitioners who proposed to file or support complaints against her.

The commission concluded that these actions constituted a “pattern of victimisation.” Prapas was also found to have made an offensive comment about an individual from a marginalised group and an unprofessional remark about a fellow judicial officer.

In her written response, Prapas acknowledged that her conduct was “unfiltered and intemperate” at times and that she would have expressed herself differently with hindsight. She highlighted the unique therapeutic environment of the drug court, explaining that her intent was to promote participant recovery, accountability and community safety.

She added that she had reflected carefully on the issues raised and taken steps to ensure her communication remains effective, respectful and less prone to misinterpretation.

The watchdog was unable to substantiate certain allegations, including claims of cultural insensitivity.

In delivering its decision, the commission recognised that drug court proceedings may require “open and frank” discussions. “However, these features do not replace a judicial officer’s duty to treat all court users with civility and respect,” it stated.

The primary complaint has been referred to Chief Magistrate Lisa Hannan, who has been advised to counsel Prapas.

Additional recommendations include requiring Prapas to familiarise herself with the commission’s conduct guidelines and to attend an educational session within the next year.

Source link