Making defensive substitutions is a perfectly valid tactical choice when it pays off, but when it backfires, a manager will face immense scrutiny.
During the World Cup round of 16, England found themselves leading 2-1 against Mexico at the Azteca Stadium when Jarell Quansah was shown a red card.
Tuchel responded by sending on three defenders in exchange for a defender, a midfielder, and a forward.
Yet, England held on to win 3-2, and Dan Burn’s impactful cameo became the stuff of legend.
However, just nine days later, with England leading 1-0 against Argentina, Tuchel opted for the exact same formula—bringing on three defenders to replace a defender, a midfielder, and a forward.
The first of these changes, replacing Anthony Gordon with Eberechi Konsa, occurred in the 72nd minute.
The side retreated into a deep defensive block, ultimately watching Argentina break their resolve.
In contrast, against Spain, even with England reduced to ten men and under relentless pressure, Tuchel was far more cautious about resorting to purely defensive substitutions.
Myles Lewis-Skelly, replacing Harry Kane, was the first to enter the pitch in the 78th minute—fifteen minutes after Anderson’s dismissal. Five minutes later, Tuchel introduced two more players, though one of them was an offensive option in Dominic Calvert-Lewin.
Dan Burn did not come on until the 89th minute, replacing fellow defender Ben White.
“Harry played for 78 minutes, Jude (Bellingham) for 83 minutes, and after that, it was just defending, defending, defending, which is incredibly tiring,” Tuchel explained.
“So, we desperately needed fresh energy. When asked yesterday about the potential for critical substitutions, I stated that I feel entirely free to make any change I believe is necessary to help the team and positively influence the game.”
“I feel fully empowered to make those decisions, and given the sheer volume of defensive work required, we simply opted for some fresh legs to inject energy into the side.”

