A tense contest to choose the next United Nations secretary-general is entering its closing weeks before a deadline that has never before been missed, with rival powers trading barbs over a field of candidates in an opaque and closely guarded selection process.
Eight contenders, rounds of secret ballots and simmering geopolitical rivalries have left the outcome uncertain, even though Antonio Guterres must step down on December 31.
Competing agendas stretching from the Americas to the Middle East have slowed the process and raised the prospect that, for the first time in the organisation’s history, the new year might open with no one leading the world’s foremost diplomatic body. The recent arrival of two candidates, Emirati diplomat Lana Nusseibeh and Turkish nominee Feridun Sinirlioglu, has opened the race further, with no single name yet clearing the opposition of all five veto-holding permanent members of the UN Security Council (UNSC).
The drawn-out battle is part of a broader “contest over who will hold political influence within the UN at a moment when multilateralism is under severe strain and attack”, said Georgina Holmes, senior lecturer in politics and international studies at the Open University in the United Kingdom.
“The P5 are less politically aligned than in earlier eras, arguably even during the Cold War,” Holmes noted, referring to the council’s permanent members.
‘The most difficult job in the world’
The secretary-general has often been likened to a “secular pope”, a unifying figure expected to anchor global diplomacy.
Yet the role extends far beyond that of a figurehead. The secretary-general is also the UN’s senior administrator, responsible for appointing top officials and overseeing a Secretariat made up of tens of thousands of staff.
“The secretary-general has to be a shrewd politician to steer through geopolitics, a capable diplomat and mediator to resolve disputes, a commanding public presence and a competent administrator,” said Jan Klabbers, professor of international law at the University of Cambridge. “It is called ‘the most difficult job in the world’ for a reason.”
This year’s contest unfolds as the UN, under Guterres, faces mounting pressure, having been sidelined from conflicts in Iran and Ukraine. It has drawn sharp criticism from US President Donald Trump and is grappling with a financial crisis that has forced the loss of thousands of jobs.
Geopolitical tensions are now extending to the candidates themselves, who are being judged closely on their nationalities and policy positions.
Who is in the running?
Eight candidates nominated by member states are competing to succeed Guterres. Most hail from Latin America or the Caribbean, consistent with the UN’s informal regional rotation, and five of the eight are women, reflecting a push to appoint the organisation’s first female chief.
According to a series of anonymous straw polls conducted by the UNSC to measure support, a leading contender is Costa Rican diplomat Rebeca Grynspan.
In the most recent poll on November 5, which does not disclose how individual council members voted, Grynspan drew 12 “encourage” votes and three “discourage” votes, according to PassBlue, a nonprofit that covers the UN.
Grynspan, who leads the UN Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD), has been cast as a “continuity candidate”, though questions remain about whether she would deliver sufficient reform for an organisation under intense political and financial strain.
Richard Gowan, programme director of global issues and institutions at the International Crisis Group, said Grynspan had “cemented her status as the frontrunner”, even as she still faces potential opposition from the United States and Russia, either of which could block her.
While she has steered clear of directly confronting any veto-wielding power, some UNCTAD reports under her leadership have voiced concern over Israel’s conduct in Gaza and the occupied West Bank, stances that diverge from Washington’s unequivocal support for Israel. She has also previously challenged Russia’s rationale for suspending the deal that had allowed grain shipments through the Black Sea.
At the same time, she, like the other candidates, is understood to be courting key member states. In April, she met with Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov to discuss her bid.
“Grynspan’s team believes they can still bring Washington and Moscow around, and US officials do appear to be keeping the door open to working with her in the end,” Gowan said.
To win, a candidate must secure at least nine votes in favour among the 15-member UNSC while avoiding a veto from any of its five permanent members: the US, the UK, France, Russia and China. The 193-member UN General Assembly must then give its approval.
Ben Donaldson, an adviser to the 1 for 8 Billion campaign, a civil society initiative “advocating for a fair, open and inclusive way to select the next secretary-general”, cautioned that opposition in a straw poll does not automatically translate into a veto.
“It has been used before as leverage to extract concessions from a candidate, often in the form of a backroom arrangement to secure a P5 national a senior post in the incoming secretary-general’s cabinet,” he told Al Jazeera.
Rafael Grossi, the Argentine head of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), is also in the race. He placed second in the latest straw poll with nine “encourage” and four “discourage” votes. His reputation for close alignment with Washington is expected to hurt him with some permanent members, particularly China and Russia, though he has offered warm words for Beijing and Moscow in recent weeks.
The other Latin American and Caribbean candidates are Guyanese diplomat Carolyn Rodrigues Birkett, Antigua and Barbuda’s Maria Fernanda Espinosa and Ecuador’s Ivonne A-Baki.
Rodrigues Birkett, whose characterisation of Israel’s actions in Gaza as “genocide” has attracted attention in the US, drew five “discourage” votes in the latest poll. Espinosa and A-Baki received 10 and 14 “discourage” votes respectively, dimming their prospects.
The recent nominations of the UAE’s Lana Nusseibeh and Turkiye’s Feridun Sinirlioglu have reshaped the contest, though both face substantial resistance.
Nusseibeh is reportedly favoured by the US and Russia, but her candidacy has encountered pushback over allegations that her country has armed paramilitary forces accused of atrocities in Sudan, a claim the United Arab Emirates denies. She received six “discourage” votes in the latest poll.
“Nusseibeh’s central hurdle is winning over China, which has so far seemed sceptical about her candidacy,” Gowan said. “If she can secure Beijing’s backing, she could break through.”
Sinirlioglu’s candidacy, which UNSC member Greece is expected to oppose, received eight “discourage” votes.
Ugandan politician Olara Otunnu, the sole remaining African contender, drew nine “discourage” votes.
Far-right former Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban, though not an official candidate, has been floated by the US as an outside option, according to The Wall Street Journal.
A UN in ‘near-constant crisis’
Several analysts said Grynspan appears best placed, but the clout of the P5 could still shift the race.
Earlier this month, the US and Russia backed the UAE’s Nusseibeh, with France and the UK offering “little resistance”, according to diplomats cited by the platform Devex.
China, meanwhile, has signalled a preference for a Latin American candidate, The New York Times reported, though Beijing has stopped short of publicly endorsing anyone.
Ellen Ravndal, associate professor of political science at the University of Stavanger in Norway, said the protracted selection and the difficulty of reaching consensus reflect an age of “greater geopolitical tensions” and a UN stuck in “near-constant crisis mode”.
Adam Day, head of the Geneva office of the United Nations University Centre for Policy Research, noted that while this leadership race has been longer and more fractious than the cycles that produced Guterres in 2016 and Ban Ki-moon in 2006, some earlier contests stretched into December.
“In the wider history of secretary-general races, this one is still within the normal range,” Day said. “But the longer it drags on, the less time the incoming secretary-general has to prepare a transition.”
Should no successor be chosen by year’s end, the UN Charter lays out no automatic interim replacement. Any vacancy would therefore require the UNSC and other UN bodies to agree on how to handle the organisation’s leadership and operations.
“There is broad concern that the United States, and possibly other influential states, are deliberately running down the clock, perhaps to pressure members into accepting a less popular candidate or to leave the UN leaderless and weakened for a time,” Donaldson said.
Also Read
- K-Electric Reschedules Board Meeting to November 17, 2026
- Beyond the Refund: The Hidden Profit Drain of E-Commerce Returns in Southeast Asia
- BMW Recalls 720,796 Vehicles Over Fire Risk From Defective Water-Pump Connector
- IRGC Says Mines Triggered Explosions Aboard Two Oil Tankers in Strait of Hormuz

