Five EU member states have unveiled plans to establish an offshore processing centre in Rwanda for individuals lacking legal permission to remain in Europe. The pilot initiative is expected to draw legal challenges and has been condemned by critics as “a grave moral failing”.
Germany, Austria, the Netherlands, Denmark and Greece are the first nations to invoke the EU’s newly adopted returns legislation, which permits the transfer of individuals who have exhausted all appeals against deportation to a third country.
In a joint statement on Monday, the five governments announced that “concrete negotiations with partner country Rwanda will begin for implementation,” adding that the programme would make “an important contribution to further curbing illegal migration, dismantling the business model of smugglers and relieving pressure on our populations”.
Officials aim to transfer approximately 100 people to Rwanda in early next year as a trial of the model. The initiative will apply to adults whose asylum claims have been denied, as well as others without legal residency rights in the EU.
According to diplomatic sources, individuals would reside at a reception centre in Rwanda for several months before opting either to integrate into Rwandan society or return to their countries of origin.
Unlike the abandoned British Conservative initiative in Rwanda or Italy’s agreement with Albania, this scheme will not apply to individuals currently pursuing asylum claims.
The countries described the reception centre as an open facility intended not for long-term detention but to manage regular arrivals. Diplomatic sources confirmed that the EU nations are not utilising British-funded facilities constructed in Kigali.
The participating governments contend that the plan will safeguard the European asylum system and eliminate incentives for irregular migration to the continent.
Morten Bødskov, Denmark’s immigration minister, whose government has pioneered a strict migration approach widely followed across the EU, called the move “a huge breakthrough”.
German Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt stated: “Return hubs offer a constructive approach for individuals without the right to remain and with no prospects in Europe, particularly where their countries of origin do not cooperate with repatriation.”
Andy Burnham told reporters last week that the UK has not engaged in direct discussions with the European governments behind the return hubs, adding that “we will watch that with interest, learning from what went on in the past. The public want us to do whatever we can to deal with illegal immigration.”
Critics have pointed to the ethical complications of partnering with Rwanda’s government, which the US State Department found in 2024 to permit state security forces and civilian officials to commit human rights abuses with impunity. The agreement has also drawn concerns over freedom of expression and forced labour.
Pedro Sánchez, Spain’s socialist prime minister, said on Monday that the initiative had no “future or humanity.” “I don’t see any future or humanity in that. It’s not the solution,” Sánchez, an outspoken advocate for migration in a Europe that has shifted rightward in recent years, told Telecinco television.
French Green MEP Mélissa Camara denounced the pact between the five countries and Rwanda as “an agreement of shame” and “a grave moral failing.” She said: “Under this agreement, people will be deported thousands of kilometres from the European Union, with no guarantees regarding the protection of their rights.”
Alain Berset, secretary general of the Council of Europe, the continent’s human rights body, said it was not possible “to be so precise a priori” about the implications of any return hubs proposal. Speaking to the Guardian before the announcement, he stressed that all Council of Europe members remain committed to the European Convention on Human Rights, “and this must be the lighthouse” for discussions on return hubs.
“On concrete cases, we will have to see if this complies with the convention,” he said. He emphasised that “all countries must be able to define their migration policy.”
Officials establishing the migration centres anticipate legal challenges but maintain that the scheme is grounded in human rights law.
Rights organisations argue the scheme is destined to fail. “Member states may label them ‘return hubs’ or even ‘welcome centres,’ but no euphemism can conceal the violence of uprooting people from the lives they have built in Europe and sending them to a country they do not know, without family, networks or meaningful prospects,” said Chiara Catelli of Picum, a pan-European organisation advocating for undocumented migrants.
Also Read
- Cincinnati Zoo’s Fiona the Hippo Under Veterinary Care After Swallowing Visitor’s Hat
- Situational Awareness Re-Entered AI Stocks at Full Leverage Before October Selloff, Renewing Questions About a Misjudged Bet
- Chipotle Introduces ‘Sneak It In’ Hoodie: Insulated Pocket Keeps Burritos Warm for Movie Nights
- Rubio and Bahraini Foreign Minister Al Zayani Deepen Gulf Security Assurance

