The High Court of Justice dismissed the prosecution’s petition on Thursday, concluding that a recent adjustment in the defense’s stance had already achieved the practical outcome prosecutors had sought.
The ruling permits prosecutors to cross‑examine former attorney‑general Avichai Mandelblit and any future defense witnesses according to the arrangement set by the Jerusalem District Court on Wednesday, though it does not resolve the larger legal issue the prosecution had presented.
Supreme Court President Isaac Amit, together with Justices Yael Willner and Khaled Kabub, noted that the matter raised a substantial question and determined that the petition was no longer the proper forum for resolution. Consequently, they cancelled Sunday’s hearing and the conditional order issued on Tuesday.
The prosecution unusually challenged an interim decision in the ongoing criminal trial, asserting that the restrictions hindered its ability to ascertain the facts and could impact related proceedings.
At issue concerned the November 2 decision that limited prosecutors to re‑examination of Mandelblit’s testimony, while allowing requests for a different approach on particular points. Netanyahu had called Mandelblit as a defense witness, and the defense’s questioning had effectively functioned as cross‑examination.
This distinction shapes how lawyers test a witness’s account: cross‑examination enables the opposing side to challenge testimony, including via leading questions, whereas re‑examination is typically limited to clarifying issues raised during cross‑examination.
Prosecutors claim they could not adequately confront Mandelblit
Mandelblit’s testimony raised concerns about his role in authorizing the investigations into Netanyahu and the indictment. Prosecutors argued that the restrictions impeded their ability to confront him with documents and to address gaps and contradictions regarding events from about a decade ago.
The dispute also broadened beyond Mandelblit. The petition noted that earlier District Court rulings had limited prosecution questioning of witnesses initially listed by the state but later summoned by the defense. The reasoning cited the witnesses’ perceived alignment with the prosecution and relied on a civil case precedent.
Mandelblit was not on the prosecution’s witness list—a point the state stressed, arguing that the rule concerning unused prosecution witnesses did not apply to him.
On Wednesday, defense attorneys withdrew their objection to prosecution cross‑examination on practical and procedural grounds, while still preserving their legal arguments.
District Court Judges Rivka Friedman‑Feldman, Moshe Bar‑Am, and Oded Shaham stated they would continue to handle defense witnesses accordingly, explicitly including Mandelblit, without altering their prior decisions on witnesses who had already testified.
Prosecutors nevertheless requested a High Court clarification of the law, arguing that the new arrangement was based on agreement rather than a legal ruling, and sought confirmation that maintaining earlier decisions meant only that witnesses whose questioning had concluded would not be recalled again—an arrangement the state had already indicated it would not pursue.
The High Court concluded that the practical relief sought had been attained.
High Court Notes It Is ‘Not Self‑Evident’ That Civil Precedent Applies
Its discussion, however, highlighted reasons to question the earlier restrictions. The justices referenced a 2012 judgment indicating that prosecutors could cross‑examine a witness they had listed but declined to call once the defense called that witness.
They also observed that it was “not self‑evident” that the civil precedent could be applied to the present issue, a point that had not yet been clarified in the court’s case law.
However, the justices expressly refrained from deciding the matter, stating that it would also be inappropriate to do so while the respondents’ substantive arguments remained unheard.
The outcome concludes the High Court proceedings without endorsing or overturning the District Court’s earlier legal reasoning, and prosecution cross‑examination will continue under the Wednesday arrangement.
Netanyahu’s trial, which began in May 2020, is now in its defense stage. He faces fraud and breach‑of‑trust charges in all three cases, as well as bribery in Case 4000, and maintains his innocence.
Also Read
- Syrian Christian Patriarchs Warn of Existential Threat Amid Surge in Violence and Extortion
- APEC Bets on Open Markets to Reignite Trade Growth
- UK Expels Myanmar Defense Attaché Following ICJ Genocide Ruling on Rohingya
- Beijing Trilateral Summit Issues Joint Peace Initiative as Leaders Discuss Ukraine, Nuclear De‑Escalation and Global Cooperation
