Denmark’s Morten Bødskov hailed a breakthrough, describing a new EU asylum system that would not benefit human smugglers. Germany’s Alexander Dobrindt presented the proposal as a positive approach for those lacking prospects in Europe, while Greece’s Thanos Plevris said the hubs would reduce illegal migration and increase returns.
In Vienna, a so‑called “return hub” – an open, temporary facility – is being examined by five European nations in partnership with Rwanda for asylum seekers whose claims have been rejected. The pilot would initially accommodate about 100 individuals, who, in principle, could stay in Rwanda or be relocated elsewhere if they meet the required legal criteria.
In 2022, the United Kingdom announced a plan to transfer asylum seekers to Rwanda for processing.
A year later, Britain’s Supreme Court declared the scheme unlawful, ruling that Rwanda could not be deemed safe due to institutional deficiencies and previous instances of refoulement, meaning asylum seekers risked being sent onward to face persecution.
Italy’s attempt in Albania encountered difficulties, plagued by operational failures and 2024 court rulings that forced authorities to return migrants to Italy. The EU Agency for Asylum noted in its 2026 report that inadequate judicial oversight and fundamental‑rights concerns are central to these schemes, causing rapid externalisation projects to clash with legal reality. Throughout the Union, authorities issue far more deportation orders than can be enforced; in 2025, Eurostat recorded 491,950 removal orders, but only 135,460 individuals (about 29 %) were actually returned. The shortfall stems not from insufficient detention capacity but from practical obstacles: missing travel documents, uncooperative origin countries, consular delays, and legal safeguards against removal. To address this, the EU introduced a new Return Regulation that creates a legal framework permitting member states to transfer rejected asylum seekers to non‑EU countries, provided international law is respected.
Nevertheless, the term “return” stretches the truth. Sending someone to Rwanda—a country with which they have no connection—is effectively a removal to a third‑party nation that accepts them.
If they cannot return home and do not wish to remain in Rwanda, what becomes of them? How long will they be detained there, and who guarantees that their rights are actually upheld in practice, not merely on paper?
Supporters cite Rwanda’s economic development since the 1994 genocide and its ratification of international conventions, though treaty signatures alone do not demonstrate institutional capacity or human‑rights respect. The UK Supreme Court’s findings on Rwanda’s asylum system, together with repeated reports by Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International documenting custody abuses, and a 2025 UN Security Council Group of Experts report detailing Rwanda’s alleged support for the M23 militia in eastern DR Congo, highlight serious concerns. European leaders, responding to public perception of a broken asylum system, use outward migration to signal firmness and control.
Nevertheless, beneath the charitable language of offering a “second chance” or “new beginning,” a familiar political reflex emerges: shifting a complex legal and humanitarian responsibility to a third country instead of reforming asylum and integration systems domestically.
As a resident of Lesbos, I have long struggled to discuss migration purely in policy terms. For over a decade, the island—Europe’s geographical frontier—has borne the tangible consequences: overcrowded detention camps, protracted limbo, inadequate reception conditions, and an emergency narrative that reduces people to administrative categories while expecting a small community to shoulder the continent’s failures. This experience underscores the limits of externalisation, which often redirects migration toward even more perilous routes, resulting in additional deaths.
From this viewpoint, the proposed Rwanda “return hub” appears as another effort to distance people from rights and scrutiny—a continuation of policies that have already turned the Aegean into a testing ground for measures imposed on the most vulnerable. While governments claim such hubs will curb illegal migration, the reality is that emergency rhetoric can replace the slower, more demanding work of protection, with bureaucracy and deterrence prevailing. Distance may obscure responsibility from European capitals, but it does not erase it; the obligation must be clearly defined before any individual is placed on a flight.
Also Read
- SK Hynix Poised to Become Kioxia’s Largest Shareholder via Bond-to-Equity Conversion
- Anthropic Shares Retreat Following Historic Market Debut Amid Tech Selloff
- Unraveling the Allegations: Is Pakistan Covertly Supporting Anti-Taliban Insurgents in Afghanistan?
- Lana Nusseibeh Doubles Down on ‘Relentless Diplomacy’ in UN Leadership Race

