
[Editor’s note: This review was originally published on October 2, 2026, during the 2026 New York Film Festival. Janus Films will release the film in limited theaters on Friday, November 20.]
Paul Thomas Anderson has long understood how to bring music to life on screen. His fascination dates to the late 1990s, when, following “Boogie Nights,” he crafted vivid music videos with then-partner Fiona Apple and paid tribute to Aimee Mann with the San Fernando Valley-set epic “Magnolia.” In the years since, he has collaborated with the band HAIM — casting one of its members, Alana Haim, as a lead actress — shot videos for Radiohead, and forged an ongoing creative partnership with Radiohead’s Jonny Greenwood, producing some of the most celebrated scores of the 21st century. For a generation of cinephiles, the playful, lilting melodies of “Phantom Thread” have become inseparable from the intoxicating promise of new love and obsessive artistic pursuit.


Last December, Anderson joined forces with Geese frontman Cameron Winter to capture his solo performance at Carnegie Hall, personally operating a Panavision camera as Winter worked through spare piano arrangements of songs from his solo album, “Heavy Metal.” The result is a 72-minute film that Janus Films is now rolling out in a roadshow release before, inevitably, taking its place in the Criterion Collection. It is a remarkable work in its own right — an aching, sincere concert film that never tips into earnestness for its own sake and remains tender to the point of fragility. Benny Safdie served as a co-producer, and the movie’s gritty New York texture bears his unmistakable imprint.
With his tousled hair and lean frame, Winter can appear ill at ease in the public eye, as he did onstage before the film’s world premiere at Alice Tully Hall during the New York Film Festival. At the piano, however, fully immersed in his craft, he becomes quietly electrifying. His tenor glissandos and agile fingerwork yield shiveringly delicate folk ballads that recall Harry Nilsson and Van Morrison — and while the frequent comparisons to Tom Waits and Rufus Wainwright hold merit, Winter remains an entirely singular artist. Even those unconvinced by the restless, anarchic rock of Geese — one of the most exciting contemporary art-rock bands working today — are likely to be won over here. Anderson has crafted a rhapsodic tribute that, despite its grandeur, retains an intimate, ballad-sized emotional scale.
Last December, Winter performed before a sold-out house of more than 2,700 at the storied halls of Carnegie Hall, and at moments the film evokes something closer to a religious rite — an incantation, a solitary vigil. He was 23 at the time, a year older than Bob Dylan when he headlined the venue and, like Dylan, poised on the brink of major fame. Mounted on a mobile rig that occasionally sweeps and glides across the stage when not fixed on Winter, Anderson’s camera captures the expressive play of stage lighting as it illuminates and recedes from the singer’s face, its chiaroscuro lending the performance a painterly intensity.
The finished film is hypnotic — a concert movie in the tradition of “Stop Making Sense,” though tuned to the sensibility of introverts. A track like the popular single “$0” takes on an even more wrenching melancholy as its lovelorn narrator laments being used by a lover (“You’re making me feel like a dollar in your hand / You’re making me feel like I’m a zero dollar man”). Without elaborate production, the indie favorite “Love Takes Miles” resonates even more deeply. Though many of the songs inhabit a similar key and flow into one another, the effect is all the more transfixing. Aside from a tender prologue and a moving coda, the film offers no interstitial breaks, yielding an experience that is immersive and profound — the kind of truth you feel somewhere in your body even if you cannot quite put it into words.
Grade: A-
Also Read
- When Kids Say It Their Own Way: A Ruth Chan Comic
- Music Icons Unite in Tribute to Stone Roses Bassist Gary “Mani” Mounfield on First Anniversary of His Passing
- Rooted in Nature: Two Rising Musicians Draw Inspiration from the Wild
- Yellowjackets Season 4 Finally Explores Shauna’s Relationship With Her Mother, According to Melanie Lynskey

