New York City’s official leading the effort to close Rikers Island says a new plan unveiled by Mayor Zohran Mamdani could mark a turning point in how the nation’s largest city detains people.
On Friday, Mamdani announced a proposal to shut the Rikers Island jail complex by 2032. The plan calls for opening four new jails and sharply reducing the city’s inmate population.
Efforts to close the troubled facility go back to 2019, when the City Council voted to shutter it by an earlier deadline. The timeline has since slipped amid difficulties over where to house detainees.
Dana Kaplan, whom Mamdani appointed as the city’s “Close Rikers Czar,” told BBC News that the proposal is not merely about replacing an aging jail.
She described it as a “generational opportunity” to create a different kind of detention system and to determine how people should be held more appropriately.
The Rikers complex sits on 413 acres between Queens and the Bronx and has long been known for its harsh conditions and controversial reputation, with nicknames such as “Gladiator School” and “Torture Island.” Among those held there have been Tupac Shakur, DMX and Harvey Weinstein.
About 6,500 people are detained there at any given time. Mamdani’s goal is to reduce that number to 4,100, a target the city’s correction officers’ union has criticized.
“[B]uilding a new system that puts an arbitrary cap on the City’s available jail beds is ill-conceived, irresponsible and jeopardizes the safety of all New Yorkers, including our Officers,” NYC Correction Officers’ Benevolent Association said in a statement. “The City cannot keep the jail population at around 4,100 without irresponsibly releasing individuals who committed violent felony charges.”
Kaplan rejected that argument.
“It’s actually possible to have fewer people in jail in New York City — and that is what we should be planning for,” she said.
Rikers has faced years of criticism over staffing shortages, deteriorating conditions and deaths in custody, including nine this year. A law required the jail to close by 2027, but Mamdani attributed delays to the previous administration of former Mayor Eric Adams and the coronavirus pandemic.
Last year, a federal judge removed Rikers from the city’s control and appointed an outside official to oversee decisions related to the facility.
In an 88-page report released Friday, Mamdani said Rikers was the result of deteriorating infrastructure and that closing it was a moral imperative.
The City Council must approve the revised timeline, though council members, including the city’s speaker, have signaled support for the plan.
Mamdani’s office said the city plans to open four new jails: one in Brooklyn by 2029, two in the Bronx and Queens by 2031, and one in Manhattan by 2032.
The mayor’s office said the smaller facilities would give detainees better access to daylight, fresh air and clean space, potentially improving outcomes. The new jails would also be easier for families to visit than remote Rikers Island, where travel can take hours.
Mamdani said his administration would seek to reduce incarceration citywide by expanding alternatives to detention for some defendants awaiting trial, making it easier for families to post bail online and accelerating the pretrial legal process.
He also plans to add hundreds of beds in therapeutic housing units for detainees with serious mental health needs.
Kaplan said the administration has already opened 100 therapeutic beds at Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan, allowing 100 people to be moved from Rikers Island.
The proposal includes significant investments, including $146 million (£111 million) for mental health and substance-use treatment, as well as vocational and educational programs inside and outside the jails.

