Defence Intelligence Chief Warns of Miscalculation Risk and Outlines Three Missions at Cambridge
The Chief of Defence Intelligence used an address at the Cambridge Intelligence Seminar to warn that the global security environment is deteriorating and to set out how Defence Intelligence is adapting to a more dangerous era. Speaking at Corpus Christi College, he thanked Professor Chris Andrew, the seminar’s convener, noting that Andrew had supervised him in intelligence history three decades earlier and praising his profound influence on the discipline and the intelligence community.
He recalled Andrew’s famous collaboration with Oleg Gordievsky, the KGB resident in London who worked as an agent for MI6 and was exfiltrated from the Soviet Union in 1985. His favourite story concerned Operation RYAN in the early 1980s, when Gordievsky and his colleagues counted how many lights remained on late at night in the Ministry of Defence’s Main Building in Whitehall. The theory was that the more lights left burning, the more likely senior officers and officials were to be planning a strike on the Soviet Union.
The Chief said that, from his intelligence training, he doubted this was ever a particularly good indicator of British military intentions in the early 1980s—and it certainly was not now. However, as he often works late into the evening in MOD Main Building, he could not help seeing similarities with that era. No one wants war, he said, but the UK must remain watchful and vigilant and do all it can to prevent it.
He described the contrast between the peaceful view of everyday London from his window down the Thames and the concerning papers he reads at his desk. The threats are manifest, he said: the ongoing war in Ukraine; the wider risk of escalation in Europe; the arc of conflict across the Horn of Africa, the Arabian Peninsula and the Middle East; the mind-boggling scale and pace of military capability build-up in East Asia; the exponential rise in AI-driven offensive cyber-attacks; and the seemingly daily reality of sub-threshold adversary operations affecting the UK and its allies.
That, he said, is why Defence Intelligence and the wider Military Intelligence Services are so important to protecting the country today. In an era of volatility, uncertainty, technological and climate change, and heightened threats, it is more important than ever that the MOD and the nation can understand and respond to the challenges. Since July he had been proud to lead an organisation of nearly 4,000 tri-service and civil service specialists.
The range of expertise within the team never ceased to amaze him, he said: national experts in cutting-edge military capabilities, talented linguists, skilled geospatial imagery analysts, courageous agent handlers, determined counter-intelligence investigators and ingenious data scientists. The key was working collaboratively so that the sum of Defence Intelligence was much greater than the individual efforts of the team. An inclusive and collegiate approach was at the core of everything it did.
He also remembered Major Paul Wilks of the Army Intelligence Corps, who was tragically killed in a road collision in Ukraine in September. Although Wilks was not serving in Defence Intelligence at the time of his death, he had served there for many years and was a highly talented and committed officer who had huge operational impact.
Defence Intelligence has three missions, the Chief said. The first is to deliver on operations today. Wherever members of the UK armed forces are deployed, Defence Intelligence personnel are alongside them—in eastern Europe, the Middle East, with partners in a range of locations and at all overseas bases. At the intelligence centre at Wyton, teams work 24/7 to monitor threats and coordinate Defence’s intelligence response to emerging crises.
Defence Intelligence also works closely with partners in the UK. The recent threats at RAF Fairford and the arrest last week of an officer assigned to the NATO Allied Rapid Reaction Corps demonstrated the need to respond to challenges at home as well as overseas. Developing the approach to homeland and national defence is one of the Chief’s top priorities, and Defence Intelligence is working with Standing Joint Command and a range of partner organisations to ensure people and bases are protected.
The second mission is to conduct vigilant deterrence. The Chief cited the Secretary of State for Defence, John Healey? No—the original says Mr. Streeting, the Secretary of State for Defence, himself also a Cambridge historian, who said in Oslo last week that the more ready the UK is to fight and win, the less likely war becomes. Defence Intelligence’s role in deterrence is to provide vigilance. Working with partners, it gains insight into adversary capabilities and developments, and their intent to use those against the UK. It cannot predict the future, but it can provide foresight to reduce uncertainty. In a murky world of cyber-attacks, drone incursions that may or may not be accidents and, as last weekend’s attempted attack in Estonia showed, increasing sabotage, Defence Intelligence’s role is to find the signal in the noise.
War-fighting readiness cannot be achieved only by boosting conventional forces, he said; it must also be done by staying at the cutting edge in the intelligence world. More equipment may glisten in the sun, but highly advanced operators and intelligence capabilities are also active in the shadows.
The third mission is to prepare for war. Alongside maritime, land, air, cyber and space forces, Defence Intelligence needs to be ready to fight in the sixth-generation battlespace. That means playing its part in being ready to find, fix, track and target adversaries. Defence Intelligence is at the forefront of transforming Defence’s targeting efforts.
The Digital Targeting Web is the underpinning capability of the Strategic Defence Review and Defence Investment Plan, and Defence Intelligence is already benefiting from the resources flowing from it. The aim is to help connect an array of sensors with the armed forces’ weapons systems through a “single pane of glass”—a common intelligence picture providing clarity on an ever-foggier battlefield.
Defence Intelligence also needs to play its role in protecting the armed forces from attacks and deception. Money allocated to the Targeting Web in the SDR is already having an impact and enabling improved collaboration with allies and partners. Later this month, the Cyber and Specialist Operations Command, of which Defence Intelligence is part, will bring into operation a new sensitive capability that will greatly enhance the ability to acquire targets and provide more precise data to frontline forces—a key stepping stone to equipping forces for the modern battlefield.
It will not surprise you, he said, that Defence Intelligence is spending a lot of time looking at how the wars in Ukraine and the Middle East are being fought, taking advantage of those lessons and helping to ensure the UK could fight and win in this environment if required. Warfare is being transformed seemingly daily through the combination of artificial intelligence and uncrewed systems, and Defence Intelligence is helping the armed forces adapt to the opportunities and challenges this poses.
These missions are achieved by enabling effective decisions, protecting the force and the nation, driving targeting and executing a range of overt and covert effects. All of this is done in a legal and policy-compliant manner, and the Chief welcomed the robust oversight of Parliament’s Intelligence and Security Committee.
He said there were limits to what he could say in an open seminar, but he wanted to give a flavour of Defence Intelligence’s activities. Enabling effective decisions sounds straightforward but is vital to effective military strategy and operations. Just as in life, everyone weighs up options constantly and makes choices based on varying sources of sometimes conflicting data, so it must be in Defence. Defence Intelligence cannot predict the future but can reduce uncertainty to enable the best choices, often in time-pressured and constrained situations:
- What is the likelihood of an adversary conducting a surprise attack against an ally, and what would they do if they did?
- Will there be a coup in that country, and what is the threat to British nationals located there if there is?
- Do those terrorists really have the capability to attack that British base, and how can that threat be neutralised?
- When will that adversary achieve success with its new surface-to-air missile system, and how can British countermeasures be ensured to protect against it?
These give a flavour of the types of questions Defence Intelligence is routinely called upon to answer. It does this by fusing together a range of sources, from the most sensitive intelligence to openly accessible information. At the core of this work is the judgment of highly trained and skilled analysts operating across a range of high-tech systems, providing assessment in an objective and dispassionate manner. The so-called Butler principles, established in the wake of the 2003 Iraq War, underpin the work, and the Chief is constantly proud to see junior colleagues having the moral courage to speak truth to power and senior colleagues being ready to listen and accept this. Unlike adversaries, Defence Intelligence will never skew assessments to satisfy a preconceived decision.
As a much younger officer, he learned the importance of intelligence to force protection as Task Force Helmand’s Brigade Intelligence Officer in southern Afghanistan. His team was constantly seeking to ensure it had the best possible intelligence picture of where the Taliban were laying IEDs, preparing ambushes or planning mortar and missile attacks. Once that intelligence was obtained, it was critical to ensure it reached the frontline in time for battle groups to act to avoid and neutralise those threats.
Today the adversary and geography might be different, but the intelligence force-protection mission remains vital. Whenever a British warship, aircraft or Army unit heads into harm’s way, Defence Intelligence plays its role in ensuring it is prepared and protected—whether that is a Royal Fleet Auxiliary ship in the Arabian Sea, an RAF Rivet Joint reconnaissance aircraft heading towards the High North or the Army battle group in Estonia. Defence Intelligence takes this duty incredibly seriously.
It also ensures the whole of Defence is protected from hostile intelligence and espionage. The arrest in Gloucestershire earlier this month demonstrated that the threat is very real. There can be no complacency, as enemies are actively seeking to steal secrets.
However, the formation of the Defence Counter Intelligence Unit earlier this year, delivering a Strategic Defence Review commitment, marked a considerable step forward. The DCIU is already proving its worth at home and overseas. Defence Counter Intelligence, working alongside many partners, played a considerable role in the arrest of the US service person. Like conventional forces, this shows how Defence Intelligence is at the frontline of tackling and deterring threats.
Defence Intelligence also executes a range of effects in conjunction with partner organisations. Most of these are covert and need to stay in the shadows for reasons that will be understood, but the Chief looked forward to future historians combing the archives to discover the feats involved. He was sure it would be a topic ripe for consideration at the seminar during the Michaelmas term of 2056 and looked forward to being invited back to participate.
In the meantime, he was pleased to talk about some of the overt effects Defence Intelligence achieves, because although much of its work is secret, not all of it is. The most conspicuous example is its posts on X, formerly Twitter, about Russia’s illegal war with Ukraine. Since February 2022, these have achieved a remarkable readership of nearly half a billion impressions, by some margin the UK’s most-read national security communication. Through a carefully controlled declassification mechanism, the aim is to undermine the legitimacy of Putin’s war and provide objective facts and assessment on what is really happening on the ground.
All this work is achieved in conjunction with the intelligence agencies, with whom Defence Intelligence collaborates very closely, and a range of partners within Defence and wider government.
Within Defence Intelligence, personnel are active players in all of the “ints”: HUMINT for human intelligence; SIGINT and ELINT for signals and electronic intelligence; GEOINT and IMINT for geospatial and imagery intelligence; MASINT for measurement and signature intelligence; and OSINT for open-source intelligence. Defence Intelligence is a key component of the Cyber and Specialist Operations Command, at the leading edge of the drive to be ready for the sixth-generation battlespace. The power of combinations that comes from working alongside the Defence and National Cyber Forces, Special Forces and Permanent Joint Headquarters is manifest.
Not only does the UK retain some of the world’s most potent intelligence agencies, but it also obtains unique value from its intelligence alliances. Foremost among these is membership of the Five Eyes, the most powerful intelligence alliance in human history. This year the original UK-US SIGINT agreement celebrates its 80th birthday, and the full Five Eyes reaches the ripe—and, the Chief very much hoped, still youthful—age of 70 after Australia, Canada and New Zealand joined in 1956. Not a day goes by when he is not grateful for it, he said, and national security is much stronger as a result of Five Eyes membership. The UK is also a member of NATO, the most powerful collective security alliance in human history.
Earlier this week he spent two days in Brussels meeting fellow intelligence chiefs from across the Alliance. There were 83 military and civilian agencies represented, and he was struck by the incredible power of intelligence combinations this represented.
He came away with an absolute resolve that the UK, as the European member of the Five Eyes and a leading NATO contributor, must do all it can to further assist the Alliance. Within Defence Intelligence, a range of projects is underway to invigorate intelligence collaboration with NATO colleagues, including a focus on the ten-member Joint Expeditionary Force of northern NATO nations, of which the UK is the framework lead. This complements work to ensure a sharpened focus on both national and homeland defence.
That focus is unfortunately required because the threat to the nation is real and growing. The Chief said he was not the first official, officer or minister to state that, and would definitely not be the last. The Russian Ground Forces may currently be fixed in Ukraine and experiencing huge casualties—often over 2,000 men a day in recent weeks and over 50,000 a month—but Russia is adapting rapidly, and the UK is very watchful about the prospects of further developments. Meanwhile, Russia’s long-range aviation, sub-surface, underwater reconnaissance, cyber, special, military intelligence, ballistic missile and nuclear forces all continue to pose a substantial threat.
With some confidence, he said, Russia does not actively seek war with NATO. However, his greatest fear is the risk of a significant miscalculation. Putin is under pressure, and that is leading to a more assertive and aggressive approach as he seeks to challenge the West. There are too many recent examples of reckless Russian behaviour where, if the incident had been slightly different, the results could have been extremely serious.
The drone attack at Leipzig in Germany, carried out by Russian proxies in August, is the most egregious recent example. At the moment, Defence Intelligence is closely following the spate of sinkings of merchant ships in the territorial waters of NATO ally Romania. From a British perspective, the Chief pointed to the Russia-backed arson attack on a Ukrainian-owned business in East London, the near shootdown of a Rivet Joint aircraft over the Black Sea in September 2022, and, further back, the Salisbury Novichok attacks that claimed one life but could have been so much worse. He wanted to be clear that the UK’s position is that it does not seek conflict or confrontation with Russia, but it will robustly defend its national security and that of its allies when threatened.
That is why Defence Intelligence’s role in providing vigilant deterrence is so important, seeking to join the dots between seemingly disparate events to inform judgments on how to respond, always seeking to adopt an objective rather than an alarmist approach. Just as it did ahead of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022, its purpose is to piece together the warning signs early, deny adversaries freedom of action, maintain advantage and give leaders the opportunity to act. Adversaries may seek surprise; the job is to deny them that, and Defence Intelligence will do its utmost to ensure this.
Given these challenges to security, the Chief said it was very welcome that the Secretary of State has set the mission of getting Britain and its allies more ready to fight and win a war in Europe by 2030. He stressed this is not a prediction of when Britain and its allies will come under military attack, but the threats make such an approach eminently sensible.
Defence Intelligence is absolutely playing its part in the transformation necessary to achieve this. In addition to its role on the intelligence frontline now and its vital role within the Digital Targeting Web, it is embracing the SDR’s intelligence-focused recommendations. The Chief had his dog-eared copy of the SDR with him and knew them well; they are at the forefront of Defence Intelligence and Cyber and Specialist Operations Command efforts.
Measures are being taken to invest more in people to ensure the organisation attracts, retains and trains the best military and civil service workforce for future challenges.
Defence Intelligence has established Military Intelligence Services, which the Chief is proud to lead, providing a lead command for intelligence, surveillance and reconnaissance across the armed forces and bringing greater coherence and prioritisation to the whole of Defence’s intelligence enterprise. In this endeavour, Defence Intelligence is grateful for the support of Louise Sander-Jones, the Minister for the Armed Forces and herself a proud veteran of the Army’s Intelligence Corps.
Defence Intelligence is also working actively with the intelligence agencies to ensure linkages are both strong and seamless. Central to this is improving connectivity between systems to ensure a rapid flow of data. The system works well now, but there is a need to work harder and faster to ensure mechanisms designed for the age of counter-terrorism and counter-insurgency are ready for the much more intense challenges of war with a hostile state.
In this journey, the Chief sees huge opportunities in artificial intelligence, and he knows agency colleagues and international partners agree. Every area of intelligence—collection, assessment, targeting and force protection—will be transformed because of it. Progress is already being made, but the pace of adoption needs to accelerate. AI is now being used to do existing tasks better, but the time will soon come when it allows entirely new ways of operating. There is a need to be ready to grapple with the policy, legal and ethical dilemmas that will come with that, and Defence Intelligence is already preparing.
In conclusion, the Chief hoped he had demonstrated that the threats are real, that the MOD is doing its utmost to rise to the challenge, and that Defence Intelligence and the Military Intelligence Services are playing their part within that effort. It had been an honour to outline Defence Intelligence’s role in the national security ecosystem to such an august group. Defence Intelligence does not wish to be boastful, but it is immensely proud of the role it plays within Defence and beyond.
As an intelligence officer, he said, he is used to and encourages challenge, questions and debate, and he very much looked forward to the discussion that would follow. It was great to return to Corpus Christi, and he thanked Professor Chris Andrew again and the audience for their attention.
Also Read
- FBI Ten Most Wanted cartel leader ‘Chapo Isidro’ captured by Mexico’s ‘elite military forces’ after US help
- Pakistani Series ‘Dar-e-Nijat’ Gains Strong Appeal Among Indian Gen Z Audiences
- Drone Strike Damages Kaliningrad-Bound Cargo Vessel in Gulf of Finland
- Congressional Analysis Warns Trump-Class Warship Push Is Inflating U.S. Navy Fleet Costs by Billions

