Production
When the Avalanche first brought him in, they seemed to uncover a hidden gem. He capitalized on his first full season in Denver, posting a career‑high 40 points. However, the 2025‑26 season revealed a different story.
Colton’s totals slipped to nine goals and 24 points in 73 games, despite staying largely healthy. His ice time also dipped from 14:25 to 12:31 per game, suggesting coach Jared Bednar may have lost confidence in his consistency.
Intangibles
Colton compensates for occasional offensive troughs with speed and defensive responsibility. His willingness to chase dirty puck battles underscores his heart, even if his size is modest.
His versatility allows him to fill various roles, and his penalty‑killing diligence adds value. While his scoring waned, his 200‑foot game and high motor kept him from being entirely lost.
Overall Grade: C‑
In a season where the Avalanche dominated from start to finish, Colton often felt like a peripheral figure. Trade rumors frequently paired his name with potential cap‑clearing moves, reflecting the roster calculus.
Entering the final year of a four‑year, $16 million contract, Colton continually appeared on the trade block. He displayed moments of the potential to be more, yet never consistently matched expectations, leaving the organization to question his long‑term fit.
A Fresh Start
Colton’s tenure in Colorado ended via a trade to the Nashville Predators, reuniting him with former GM Chris MacFarland. The Predators envision a larger role for him, capitalizing on his speed and skill set for a more prominent middle‑six position.
His promising start to the 2024‑25 season hinted at a breakout, but he faltered afterward, never regaining the same rhythm. Hopefully, the new environment will allow him to rediscover that form.