Topline
The Justice Department requested a federal appellate court to reinstate criminal charges against Kilmar Abrego Garcia, who was erroneously deported to El Salvador in 2022, three months after a lower court dismissed human smuggling allegations.
Kilmar Abrego Garcia arrives at a U.S. ICE facility in Baltimore the day after a judge mandated his release from a Pennsylvania detention center.
Getty Images
Key Facts
According to a legal filing submitted to the Sixth Circuit court, the DOJ maintains that prosecutable grounds existed for targeting Abrego Garcia, asserting the prior dismissal rested on “unfounded premises,”
Tennessee federal judge Waverly Crenshaw had dismissed charges in May 2023, stating the prosecution constituted “retarded misuse of state authority” and was motivated by Abrego Garcia’s legal challenge to his deportation decision.
The DOJ disclosed it reinvestigated the case following judicial orders compelling Abrego Garcia’s return to El Salvador after his deportation was overturned by courts, with fresh evidence emerging from a 2022 traffic stop.
The prosecution was formally initiated by Acting U.S. Attorney Robert McGuire based on this renewed inquiry, which occurred separately from Abrego Garcia’s lawsuit against his removal,
The government contended the human smuggling case originated from valid apprehension regarding Abrego Garcia’s potential return to El Salvador post-court ruling.
Through its filing, the Justice Department petitioned the appeals court to overturn Crenshaw’s decision dismissing the criminal charges.
What Did The Tennessee Federal Judge State In His Verdict?
“The evidence before this Court unfortunately demonstrates prosecutorial misconduct. This determination isn’t made lightly. The facts clearly indicate that without Abrego García’s successful legal challenge against his deportation, the authorities would not have initiated this prosecution. The Executive Branch terminated its investigation into the November 2022 traffic stop. The case was resurrected solely after Abrego García succeeded in securing his constitutional rights,”
Also Read
- Australia news live: Coles blames competitor’s Ooshies for slowing sales; young people the first generation to earn less than their parents at same age
- U.S. Removes Syria From Terrorism Blacklist After 46 Years, Unlocking Path for Investment
- U.S. Plans to Revoke Up to 200,000 Visas for Asylum Seekers
- Arbitrator Orders Washington Post to Reinstate Fired Opinion Columnist Karen Attiah
