Ex-England captain Alan Shearer criticized the team’s defensive organization after a match loss, noting “far too many holes in the back four” and that opponents scored from their first clear chances.
Shearer highlighted Declan Rice’s unexpected deployment at right-back as a temporary solution for the second goal but questioned Tuchel’s long-term strategy: “Putting Declan Rice to right-back worked because he was the one that got forward… Tuchel has a decision to make.”
Shearer acknowledged Rice’s contributions but argued his strength lies in midfield, suggesting his placement at right-back represents an acknowledgment of poor squad planning.
Ex-England defender Micah Richards advised against using Rice in defense, stating: “No, I wouldn’t. He can give too much in that central midfield area. You need his energy in midfield, especially for the Mexico game at altitude.”
Richards recommended Ezri Konsa for right-back alongside John Stones, citing the pair’s experience as crucial against Mexico’s physical conditions, particularly after Konsa and Guehi were absent during a previous goal concession.
Wayne Rooney expressed broader concerns: “When England lose the ball they are so open. Against a better team, we’re in big trouble if we don’t sort that. We’re so open in midfield.” He pointed to inconsistent flank play as compounding the issues.
The article concludes that Tuchel faces critical questions about his first-choice lineup, particularly regarding defensive stability and positional clarity.
