While the Galaxy S24 remains functional, current market alternatives make it a questionable purchase for most buyers today.
Samsung’s Galaxy S24 launched in January 2024 as an $800 flagship. Over two and a half years later, the device remains capable; however, the fluctuating prices of refurbished models complicate the buying decision. Unlocked renewed units currently retail for approximately $350, while listings in superior condition or with increased storage can surpass $400. Furthermore, Samsung’s Certified “Re-Newed” S24 begins at $519.
This pricing positions the S24 against brand-new mid-range smartphones, several of which provide superior battery life, updated camera hardware, and extended software support. For consumers spending between $400 and $500, a newer device typically offers better overall value. The S24 remains a viable option only if secured at a significantly reduced price, particularly for those prioritizing a compact form factor with flagship-level performance.
Enduring Strengths of the Galaxy S24
Adam Kovacs/Shutterstock
The S24 features a 6.2-inch AMOLED display with a 120Hz refresh rate, offering a more compact footprint than many contemporary smartphones without compromising screen fluidity. The US variant is powered by the Snapdragon 8 Gen 3, which continues to deliver ample performance for daily applications and demanding games. Additionally, the device supports wireless charging and carries an IP68 rating for dust and water resistance. Buyers should note that international models may utilize the Exynos 2400 CPU, so verifying the specific model before purchasing is essential.
The camera system remains highly competent. A 50-megapixel primary sensor is paired with a 12-megapixel ultrawide lens and a dedicated 3x telephoto lens. This configuration provides the S24 with a distinct advantage over mid-range phones that rely on digital cropping for zoomed shots. However, the imaging system is not without flaws; our review found that low-light photographs can appear dark and noisy when compared to competing flagship devices.
The device also boasts a significant amount of remaining software support. Samsung has committed to seven generations of OS upgrades and seven years of security updates, extending support through 2031. While this guarantees several more years of coverage for the S24, a smartphone released in 2026 would naturally have a longer remaining update lifespan.
The Challenges of Purchasing a Refurbished Galaxy S24
Geewon Jung/Shutterstock
Battery health represents the most significant uncertainty when purchasing a used or refurbished S24. While its 4,000mAh battery performed admirably when new, enduring roughly 24.5 hours in our video rundown test, lithium-ion batteries naturally degrade over time. Consequently, our initial results cannot determine the remaining capacity in any specific second-hand device. If physical inspection is possible, navigating to Settings > Battery > Battery information allows you to assess the battery’s current health.
A cosmetic grade of “excellent” does not guarantee that the battery has been replaced. It is crucial to ask the seller whether the phone includes a new battery, what minimum battery health is guaranteed, and what the warranty covers. A lower purchase price quickly becomes less attractive if the device will soon require a battery replacement.
Samsung’s Certified Re-Newed program mitigates much of this uncertainty by including a new battery, genuine parts, and a one-year manufacturer warranty. However, the certified S24’s $519 starting price is merely $80 less than the certified refurbished S25’s $599 starting price. Consumers evaluating Samsung’s official program should compare both devices directly, rather than assuming the older model is inherently the better value.
Viable Alternatives to the Galaxy S24
Samsung
Several alternatives provide distinct advantages at a comparable price point. Our recommendations are derived from current US pricing, manufacturer specifications, and our hands-on reviews. While none surpass the S24 in every aspect, each presents a compelling reason to consider a newer device. All of the following models were released in early 2026.
Google Pixel 10a: Priced at $499, the Pixel 10a is a robust all-around choice for anyone seeking a new Android phone. It features a 6.3-inch 120Hz OLED display, a 5,100mAh battery, and seven years of OS and security updates. Our review highlighted its excellent camera software and bright display, though charging speeds are relatively slow. While its Tensor G4 processor is less powerful than the S24’s Snapdragon chip and it lacks a dedicated telephoto lens, the Pixel remains a sensible alternative for everyday photography and long-term ownership.
Nothing Phone 4a Pro: Nothing’s $499 mid-range phone boasts a larger 6.83-inch display, an aluminum unibody, and a 3.5x periscope telephoto camera. We found its battery life and still photography impressive, though video recording was less convincing. It also lacks wireless charging and receives three years of Android updates and six years of security updates—a shorter commitment than what Samsung or Google offer. It is worth considering if you desire a larger screen, distinctive design, and versatile cameras.
Samsung Galaxy A37 5G: Starting at $449.99, the A37 is the most straightforward alternative for those wishing to remain within the Samsung ecosystem. It features a 6.7-inch OLED display, a 5,000mAh battery, 45W charging, and six generations of OS upgrades. Our review praised its battery life and display, though it noted the device is not the fastest in its class. The A37’s middling processor, 6GB of RAM in the base model, and lack of a telephoto lens mean the S24 still holds advantages for gaming and photography. The newer model makes more sense if you want a larger Samsung phone with a fresh battery and a prolonged support period.
iPhone 17e: If you are open to switching to iOS and can spend $599, the iPhone 17e presents another option. It features an A19 processor, 256GB of base storage, and MagSafe charging. Its single rear camera and 60Hz display are compromises compared to the S24, so it is not an upgrade in every respect. However, it offers newer hardware and greater storage for those planning to keep their phone for several years. As our iPhone 15 value comparison explains, an older phone becomes harder to justify when its price approaches that of a newer entry-level model.
Scenarios Where the Galaxy S24 Remains Worth Buying
Tada Images/Shutterstock
Securing an unlocked S24 for approximately $300 to $350 can be an attractive purchase, particularly if you prefer its compact dimensions, flagship processor, or telephoto camera. This is a price-based judgment rather than a guarantee that every listing represents a good deal. The battery condition, storage capacity, and warranty all influence the phone’s actual worth.
Before purchasing, request the battery’s replacement history and check its condition through Samsung Members’ battery diagnostics if you can physically inspect the device. Confirm that the phone is unlocked and test the screen, cameras, charging port, and cellular connection while the return period is still active.
If the seller cannot provide reliable battery information or a reasonable return policy, paying a premium for a properly refurbished unit or choosing a new phone is likely the safer investment.
Miguel Lagoa/Shutterstock
