India’s GDP Growth Sparks Debate Over Data Accuracy

A robust rise in exports and a sharp increase in private corporate investment helped Asia’s third‑largest economy expand despite the turmoil in global energy markets, an area that economists have long monitored closely.

Exports climbed 12% even amid tariff uncertainties, buoyed by strong global demand and a weakened rupee. A 15% decline in the rupee versus the dollar likely enhanced Indian firms’ price competitiveness, lifting demand for their products.

Businesses appear to be investing in new facilities, with India’s gross fixed capital formation—key gauge of domestic public and private investment—rising by about 12% in the first quarter of the year.

Non‑government data shows that corporate investment intentions have risen in recent months, with new projects concentrated in data centers, renewable energy and metals, according to Madan Sabnavis, chief economist at Bank of Baroda, in a BBC interview.

He noted that private investment is still not economy‑wide but that the developments are clear signs of a pickup.

The strong figures prompted several private brokerages to raise their full‑year growth forecasts, yet they also ignited a heated online debate and a political spat.

Opposition leaders such as Jairam Ramesh , externallabelled the data “statistical gymnastics”, alleging that the government repeatedly altered its methodology to hide what he described as India’s grim economic situation.

A former finance secretary questioned the surge, attributing it to newly revised figures and a lower base from the prior year. The government dismissed this view , external, stating that methodological revisions are routine in GDP calculations.

The government’s stance was echoed by World Bank’s country director, Neelkanth Mishra, who said the new GDP series “cleaned up the data and significantly improved the methodology,” thereby boosting the reliability of the estimates.

However, the newly introduced GDP series—a re‑based measurement of the economy—has markedly lowered earlier GDP estimates, making the current growth rate appear higher than it would have been under the old methodology.

Beyond the technical details, former Reserve Bank Governor Raghuram Rajan has also wondered why such rapid growth has not translated into stronger job creation or higher foreign direct investment.

Stock markets, however, largely ignored the positive data.

The controversy has clouded the outlook for policymakers, who had hoped the figures would help counter rising criticism about the uneven nature of India’s growth.

Source link