Thursday, November 19, 2026

The Toronto Maple Leafs have faced intense scrutiny in recent weeks. Between a lackluster homestand, shaky goaltending, and a porous defense, there has been no shortage of issues to dissect over a very short span.

The topic generating the most debate, however, is head coach Jim Hiller’s handling of rookie forward Gavin McKenna. After opening the season in a top-six role, McKenna has since been shifted down to the third line, where he is flanked by considerably less skilled teammates.

McKenna is still learning the ropes and settling in during his first NHL campaign. The occasional mistake comes with the territory. If the Maple Leafs hope to succeed, Hiller—who has already made his share of questionable calls—needs to give McKenna the opportunity to grow into a pivotal role on this roster.

Hiller Isn’t Holding to His Word

At the outset of the season, Hiller shared a thoughtful plan for McKenna, emphasizing the goal of putting him in the best possible position to succeed. It was sensible, fair, and made complete sense: there is no need to heap the weight of a major hockey market onto an 18-year-old rookie.

Jim Hiller Toronto Maple Leafs
Toronto Maple Leafs head coach Jim Hiller (David Banks-Imagn Images)

Over the past few weeks, though, that plan appears to have gone completely off the rails, and Hiller is no longer keeping his word to put McKenna in a position to thrive. Injuries and lineup shuffling are understandable reasons for keeping him on the third line, but a coach also has to show faith that a player can shoulder an important role.

The turning point came when Hiller benched McKenna against the Buffalo Sabres and never put him back in for the remainder of the game. His post-game explanation was puzzling. The decision was highly questionable under the circumstances, especially since McKenna was precisely the kind of player you’d want on the ice to spark an offense that had gone cold.

Even before that benching, McKenna had been demoted to the third line, skating alongside a group of depth forwards including Nick Paul, Colton Sissons, and Dakota Joshua—most recently Paul and Joshua. While that unit hasn’t conceded a goal against, it has generated very little offense in return. There have also been brief stints up on the second line.

If you genuinely want him to succeed, you have to use him more. Hiller’s repeated reliance on veterans to make plays or handle key moments has failed time and again this season. McKenna may take the occasional risk, but the veterans are failing at the simple things. At this stage, if you can’t trust your veterans given how they’re performing, why not give the rookie more opportunity?

Toronto Maple Leafs forward Gavin McKenna skates against Seattle Kraken defenseman Brandon Montour (Stephen Brashear-Imagn Images)

Take the game against the Chicago Blackhawks. McKenna was flying out there and had even earned another look on the second line. Just as the Maple Leafs knotted things up, Hiller opted for Joshua—who then turned the puck over and set up Connor Bedard’s go-ahead goal. That is poor mismanagement, and leaning on a veteran in a critical moment once again backfired.

As is often the case with rookies, McKenna draws the short straw compared to the veterans. But perhaps it’s time to hold those veterans accountable for their mistakes, the same way Hiller has held McKenna.

A Problem He Can Still Fix

For all the ways Hiller has mishandled McKenna to this point, he still has the power to correct it in two meaningful ways. It is a fixable problem.

Ideally, you’d keep McKenna on the second line, but his stint alongside John Tavares and William Nylander produced dreadful results, posting an expected goals percentage of just 29.5%. With Tavares and Nylander still struggling even without McKenna, revisiting that combination isn’t appealing.

Toronto Maple Leafs forward Gavin McKenna is congratulated by teammates on the bench after scoring a goal (Stephen Brashear-Imagn Images)

Easton Cowan has looked excellent alongside Auston Matthews and Jack Roslovic, but so has McKenna. Rather than disrupt that chemistry, consider that McKenna–Matthews–Roslovic own a 54.5% xGF share. If the second line is off the table, sliding him up to the first is a simple solution. Cowan has proven he can play anywhere, so bumping him down to the second or third line—where he can focus on a more responsible game—wouldn’t be a loss.

The second option is to give McKenna more power-play time. He wasn’t overly bothered by his demotion to the second unit, yet the Maple Leafs looked far more dangerous with him on the top group than with, say, Tavares. His ability to move the puck quickly and open up passing lanes across the offensive zone stood out. The quality of chances simply isn’t close.

McKenna is a rookie, and he does need to prove he has earned his place on the team. Still, given how the veterans have performed, Hiller’s reluctance to turn to him when the club needs a spark is troubling. The way he has been deployed over the past few weeks falls short, and it needs to change.

Statistics from Money Puck.

Source link

Exit mobile version