During his brief stint with the Vikings, J.J. McCarthy faced persistent criticism for a limited arsenal—specifically, an overreliance on high-velocity throws that lacked necessary touch on intermediate and short routes. Scouts questioned his ability to layer the ball over defenders and place it softly into tight windows.
Seven weeks into his tenure with the Giants, those concerns have largely evaporated. McCarthy now ranks among the upper tier of starting quarterbacks in both big-time throw rate and average depth of target. In the Week 10 loss to the Commanders, he showcased his progress by floating a 25-yard completion over cornerback Trey Amos into the hands of rookie Malachi Fields.
The transformation traces back to last offseason, when McCarthy collaborated with quarterback coach John Beck in Orange County, California. Their sessions focused on adding finesse to his delivery rather than defaulting to maximum velocity when touch was required.
“I feel like growing up in Chicago, obviously the Windy City, there’s a lot of times where you’d cut it through that wind, and that was my way of doing it as a younger kid,” McCarthy explained. “And then also, in the offseason, you can’t go outside. So, we were confined to spaces that only have 15-20-foot ceilings. So, it was something that I really had to grow in and develop in.”
The adjustment proved difficult to master consistently.
“To really make it concrete and have that feel consistently, it was pretty hard,” he said. “It’s even harder when you’ve got guys steamrolling, trying to break you and different guys that are running at different speeds, and there’s so many factors that go into that touch.”
Meanwhile, the Giants shuffled their return game, releasing Charlie Jones and signing Xavier Gipson off the Eagles’ practice squad to provide a “spark” on kickoff and punt returns, according to special teams coordinator Chris Horton. This marks Gipson’s third stint on the roster after two separate tenures in 2025. He carries career averages of 25.9 yards on 51 kickoff returns and 9.1 yards on 74 punt returns, though ball security remains a concern—12 fumbles in 41 games, with five lost.
“I truly believe that no player is the same player until he shows you he’s the same player,” Horton said. “So, it’s our job to go out there and allow him to grow from those things that might have set him back. But I also know that this guy, when that ball has not been on the ground, he’s made teams pay.”
On the other sideline, the Jaguars will debut two defensive starters acquired at the trade deadline: safety Jessie Bates III and defensive tackle Jordan Davis. This will be the Giants’ second encounter with Davis this season; he recorded three tackles (two for loss), one sack, and one quarterback hit in Philadelphia’s 19-11 loss on November 8.
“What I really hope to see is for them to obviously know what they’re doing and have that be priority No. 1—alignment, assignment, communication—from that standpoint,” Jaguars head coach Liam Coen said. “And then just go cut it loose, let it rip, go be you. Go be who got you here. The type of player you are. You don’t need to do anything special because it’s your first game as a Jaguar. We just need you to be you, and that’s probably going to be good enough.”
Also Read
- Liam Paro Issues 24-Hour VADA Enrollment Ultimatum to Devin Haney Ahead of Unification Bout
- Patrick Mahomes Praises KC Current’s NWSL Championship Win
- Juventus Hosts Venezia FC in Serie A: TV and Live Stream Information for the 2026–27 Season
- William Karlsson’s Shootout Goal Secures 5-4 Win for Golden Knights Over Jets


