New Zealand won the toss and elected to field first during the fifth ODI of their series at Bay Oval in Mount Maunganui on 15 November. India’s batting lineup immediately attracted criticism, especially the decision to place Ishan Kishan at No. 6 while Axar Patel opened at No. 5.
Former Indian cricketer Murali Kartik questioned the tactical rationale behind demoting Kishan, expressing concern that such a placement was atypical for a player renowned for his top‑order capabilities in shorter formats.
“Why was Ishan Kishan suddenly dropped? What versatility are they expecting from him? I realise he is not in the top three, but moving him down to six — especially with Axar coming in to protect Kishan off the new ball — feels like deploying a night‑watchman in a day match, Kartik said on Cricbuzz.”
Kartik further explained his view on Kishan’s role, arguing that Kishan, known as an opener and top‑order batsman in T20 cricket, is ill‑suited for a finisher’s role in ODI cricket.
“I do not consider Kishan a finisher. On the contrary, I would promote him higher in the order, given his experience as an opener who regularly bats in the top three in T20 cricket. With Hardik Pandya and others available, there is no need to use Kishan as a finisher,” he added.
Kartik’s remarks underscored the presence of other squad members better suited to the finisher role. The debate over India’s middle‑order composition and the ideal placement of experienced batsmen continued throughout the series, as selectors and analysts presented varying perspectives on how best to balance the lineup against New Zealand’s bowling attack.

