UK Surveillance Laws Under U.S. Scrutiny Over Encryption Concerns

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

U.K. surveillance laws came under scrutiny from House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) on June 5, as concerns grew that new powers could expose communications involving U.S. officials and citizens, reports indicate.

Central to the debate was the U.K.

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

U.K. surveillance laws came under scrutiny from House Judiciary Committee Chairman Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) on June 5, as concerns grew that new powers could expose communications involving U.S. officials and citizens, reports indicate.

Central to the debate was the U.K.’s use of secret Technical Capability Notices under the Investigatory Powers Act, which critics warn could compel U.S. companies to weaken encryption or create government-mandated “backdoors.” The provision also prohibits firms from disclosing such requests without U.K. government approval.

Opponents argue this could compromise privacy, introduce systemic vulnerabilities, and undermine congressional oversight. Former intelligence official Andrew Badger likened the policy to a “standing invitation” for foreign adversaries like China, Russia, and Iran to demand similar access once one nation establishes such precedents.

“We have already seen how this ends,” Badger, a former Department of Defense official, stated in an interview with Fox News Digital.

JD VANCE ‘DIRECTLY’ CONVINCED UK TO DROP APPLE BACKDOOR DATA DEMAND, PROTECTING AMERICANS’ RIGHTS: US OFFICIAL

Rep. Jim Jordan said Republicans are “the party of common sense,” and Democrats are “the party that takes these crazy positions.”
(Kevin Dietsch/Getty Images)

Badger emphasized that mainstream encrypted platforms now serve as critical infrastructure for sensitive communications globally. “Any access point built into them becomes a permanent target. It is not a private key the requesting government gets to keep to itself,” he explained.

U.S. and British officials have repeatedly warned that hostile states like China, Russia, and Iran pose significant threats to Western security. Badger highlighted the Salt Typhoon cyberespionage operation, which he said has breached communications of senior Western officials across 80 countries.

“China didn’t succeed by breaking encryption. They exploited government-mandated access points installed by telecom providers,” Badger noted, underscoring the risks of creating exploitable vulnerabilities.

US SPIES URGED TO REFOCUS EFFORTS ON AMERICA’S BACKYARD, NEW HOUSE INTEL CHAIR SAYS

The Thames House headquarters of MI5 in London on Nov. 18, 2025. Britain’s domestic security service has warned of growing state-backed threats, including more than 20 Iran-backed plots uncovered in the UK, as lawmakers consider new legislation targeting foreign state-linked groups.
(Betty Laura Zapata/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

On the encryption issue, Badger noted that mainstream encrypted platforms now function as “de facto infrastructure for sensitive communication well beyond the consumer market.”

“Any access point built into them becomes a permanent target. It is not a private key the requesting government gets to keep to itself,” he warned.

U.S.-British cyber officials have repeatedly linked China, Russia, and Iran to threats against Western infrastructure. Badger cited the Salt Typhoon campaign as a growing concern, warning that state-backed Chinese hackers have infiltrated systems housing sensitive security information.

CHINESE BIOWEAPON SMUGGLING CASE SHOWS US ‘TRAINS OUR ENEMIES,’ ‘LEARNED NOTHING’ FROM COVID: SECURITY EXPERT

The flag of China is flown behind a pair of surveillance cameras outside the Central Government Offices.
(Roy Liu/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Reports also emerged that U.K. Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper used a burner phone during a recent trip to Beijing, raising concerns about state-sponsored espionage. Badger described this as part of a broader pattern of Chinese targeting British institutions, including cyberattacks on Downing Street officials’ phones and the 2021 leak of data for 40 million UK voters.

“The precaution [of using a burner phone] is an admission of the threat environment. The working assumption is that anything digital taken into China should be treated as potentially compromised,” Badger stated.

He criticized the contradiction in Western diplomacy: maintaining close economic ties with China while simultaneously recognizing its role as a hostile intelligence threat. “You can’t simultaneously treat China as a trusted economic partner and a hostile intelligence threat. It’s a fundamental contradiction,” he concluded.

Emma Bussey is a breaking news writer for Fox News Digital. Before joining Fox, she worked at The Telegraph with the U.S. overnight team, covering foreign affairs, politics, news, sports, and culture.

Source link