The prolonged contract negotiation that defined the Formula 1 season has now concluded, despite not generating significant headlines, as it involved a team attempting to rise from the rear of the field.
Nevertheless, Cadillac’s stakeholders could have easily dismissed Bottas after a season in which he was outqualified by teammate Sergio Perez 11‑9 and finished behind him in five of the six races they both completed. The perception of being outpaced by up to two seconds per lap in Azerbaijan and Singapore reflected poorly on the team.
Although Bottas is well regarded and respected within the organization, the postponement of exercising the contract extension clause—understood to be a one‑plus‑one arrangement—reveals significant indecision.
Since the summer, it has been evident that the team’s internal view of its development diverges sharply from that of its owners. Like most of the F1 grid, former principal Graeme Lowdon argued that merely fielding two operational cars for the opening race was a notable accomplishment, considering the compressed timeline required to establish Cadillac from the ground up.
While occasional DNFs arose from engine problems and technical oversights—such as a cross‑threaded wheel nut that forced Bottas out of the São Paulo Grand Prix—a more pronounced cluster of reliability and performance issues stems from brake‑temperature management. These problems have caused retirements due to brake and related component failures, and have also limited race performance when drivers were forced to lift‑and‑coast.
Valtteri Bottas, Cadillac Racing, Sergio Perez, Cadillac Racing
Photo by: Mark Thompson / Getty Images
Lowdon frequently framed brake‑temperature problems as typical growing‑pains for a new team, but his superiors were unconvinced. The divide between seasoned engineers and casual commentators becomes apparent; while a simple change such as larger ducts might appear to solve the issue, the underlying aerodynamic considerations make the remedy far more complex.
The underlying science is intricate, as optimal brake cooling requires careful management of airflow and temperature across both wheel axles, while also accounting for tyre characteristics. This delicate balance of compromises precludes straightforward solutions.
Bottas has repeatedly pointed out unexplained fluctuations in the team’s performance that remain poorly understood.
Given these circumstances, retaining an experienced driver pairing remains a rational choice, despite internal debates. Budkowski’s unusually hesitant replies to queries about the driver lineup underscore the notable disagreements among senior management.
TWG Motorsports CEO Dan Towriss has devoted considerable effort to guiding Colton Herta, the team’s test and reserve driver, through his transition from IndyCar to Formula 2.
Cadillac’s stated objective is to field an American driver in Formula 1.
Herta asserted full confidence in his abilities after his FP1 session in Mexico: ‘I can match anyone’s pace, I learn quickly, and I am fully prepared to secure an F1 seat.’
Colton Herta
Photo by: Kym Illman / Getty Images
Herta said: ‘Whether that means next year or the following year, I really don’t know what the plan is at the moment. We’ll have to wait and see. I think some decisions will hopefully be made within the next month.’
Herta remains on a provisional basis, while Mercedes test driver Frederik Vesti, who also competes for Cadillac in IMSA, has been included in discussions about a potential 2027 seat.
In reality, Vesti appears set for a sportscar career, having not raced in single‑seaters since 2023 when he partnered Oliver Bearman in F2 and finished second to Theo Pourchaire. Mercedes insiders view him as reliable but roughly two to three tenths slower than the team’s regular drivers.
Jak Crawford, an American reserve for Aston Martin, was not viewed as a substantial improvement over Bottas, while Esteban Ocon—recently released by Haas—was never seriously considered due to his past tensions with Perez and his known sensitivity to the technical challenges posed by the Cadillac.
Looking ahead, Ugo Ugochukwu is slated to move up to F2 for the 2025 season after winning the F3 championship this year. His reputation has improved following a challenging rookie F3 year marked by Prema‑related difficulties, and his departure from McLaren’s driver‑development program. Nonetheless, concerns persist about whether his 1.92 m stature can be accommodated within an F1 cockpit without affecting performance, given the current formula’s packaging constraints.
For the 2027 season, the driver lineup will remain unchanged. This underscores a consensus—however uneasy—that Cadillac’s principal obstacle is car performance, and that releasing Bottas would not resolve the issue.
Also Read
- New Jersey Devils Notebook: Mantha’s Surgery, Kovacevic’s Timeline, a Power-Play Shake-Up, and Luke Hughes’ New Off-Ice Role
- This Week’s Betting Card: Fade Michigan’s Struggling Offense, Back Tennessee to Cover
- Three Suspects Arrested Following Burglary Attempt at Sloane Stephens’ Residence
- Bay FC Welcomes England Defender Jess Carter After Gotham FC Exit


