Following a tepid July, the S&P 500 is on track to close August with a gain of roughly 3%. This upswing arrives at a pivotal juncture: the approach of September—a month historically regarded as the weakest period for equities, often delivering average declines.
The underlying causes of the so-called “September Effect” remain somewhat elusive. Some analysts attribute the phenomenon to investors harvesting gains after the summer holiday season, redirecting profits toward back-to-school expenses. Others propose it operates as a self-fulfilling prophecy, where the widespread expectation of declines triggers selling pressure.
Image source: Getty Images.
August’s Impressive Run
Before examining what lies ahead, it’s worth understanding the catalysts behind August’s positive performance. Falling oil prices contributed to improved investor sentiment, alongside a robust slate of corporate earnings reports. With 97% of S&P 500 constituents having reported second-quarter results, 86% exceeded earnings per share estimates, while 77% posted revenue beats, according to FactSet’s Earnings Insight report compiled by analyst John Butters.
Notably, the “Magnificent Seven” technology stocks delivered exceptional quarterly results, potentially easing investor concerns regarding the trajectory of artificial intelligence (AI) expansion. In preceding months, certain investors had grown cautious about these mega-cap tech names as companies poured billions into AI infrastructure—worried that the eventual revenue opportunity might not validate such capital expenditures.
However, throughout the latest reporting period, technology companies continued highlighting robust AI demand. The “Magnificent Seven” achieved their highest earnings growth rate—exceeding 118%—since at least the fourth quarter of 2020, per Butters. Simultaneously, prior price declines had pushed several of these stocks to attractive valuation levels, making them compelling purchases for investors seeking AI exposure. For instance, AI chip leader Nvidia traded at a forward earnings multiple as low as 21x during August.
The Heaviest-Weighted S&P 500 Constituents
It’s essential to recognize that Nvidia and its “Magnificent Seven” counterparts carry the largest weighting within the S&P 500, meaning their performance significantly influences the index’s direction.
To assess what August’s gains might indicate for the remainder of the year, we can reference research from Carson Investment Research. Their analysts examined 11 years between 1945 and 2017 in which the S&P 500 posted positive August and year-to-date returns. In nearly every instance, the index subsequently delivered an average gain of 1% in September, followed by an average advance of 5.6% across the final four months of the year.
These historical patterns suggest that if the S&P 500 continues following this established trajectory, it could be poised for further gains in September and through year-end.
What does this mean for investors? While historical trends cannot guarantee future outcomes, they provide valuable context for informed decision-making.
Perhaps most importantly, regardless of short-term fluctuations over a month or a quarter, there are compelling reasons for long-term optimism. The S&P 500 has historically trended upward over extended periods, making any time appropriate for considering high-quality individual stocks or index-tracking funds—and holding them for the long haul.
