On Thursday, the International Court of Justice took an unprecedented step in its 80‑year history by holding a state accountable for genocide, voting nine to six to determine that Myanmar’s 2017 campaign against the Rohingya met the gravest threshold of international law.

This finding is significant because Myanmar’s defense was not merely that no atrocity occurred; it contended that its “clearance operations” were a response to attacks by the Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA), framing them as brutal yet legitimate counter‑terrorism measures. Genocide, however, demands proof not only of killings, rapes, or village destruction but also of specific intent to exterminate a protected group.

The court determined that Myanmar’s security forces killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, perpetrated extensive sexual violence, subjected children to extreme brutality, and attacked those fleeing toward Bangladesh. Collectively, the evidence led the court to infer that the sole reasonable conclusion was an intent to destroy a substantial portion of the Rohingya community in northern Rakhine State.

This decision dismantles the longstanding evasion that has dominated the past decade. While the ARSA attacks were genuine and armed conflict existed, rebellion cannot serve as a legal justification for genocide, nor can the atrocities be written off as the actions of rogue soldiers. This judgment holds Myanmar, as a state, accountable for its actions against a people.

Although the 9‑to‑6 split will inevitably be exploited by Myanmar to cast doubt on the decision, the judgment is final and binding. Moreover, by a 10‑to‑5 margin, the court ordered reparations, including the safe, voluntary, and dignified return of refugees, family reunification, property restitution, and compensation where restitution cannot be achieved.

For Rohingya survivors, this verdict represents extraordinary vindication. Yasmin Ullah, a Rohingya rights activist present in the courtroom, hailed it as “a great day for the Rohingya.” In Cox’s Bazar, refugees have long demanded not only return but also the restoration of rights, citizenship, and dignity.

Nevertheless, the reality is stark: a judgment cannot provide food, shelter, or safety; it cannot rebuild a destroyed village or guarantee a child’s safety within a refugee camp.

The ICJ lacks an enforcement mechanism. Pursuant to Article 94(2) of the UN Charter, any non‑compliance may be referred to the UN Security Council, where permanent members such as China or Russia could veto action. Consequently, external pressure is essential—targeted sanctions, ASEAN diplomatic efforts, the ICC investigation, and Argentina’s universal‑jurisdiction case, which has already issued arrest warrants for 25 suspects.

The territorial control has shifted as well. In 2017, Myanmar’s military dominated Rakhine State, but today the Arakan Army controls most of the region, with UN investigators documenting forced recruitment, movement restrictions, arbitrary killings, and other abuses against Rohingya under its governance.

Any credible return framework must therefore engage the current de facto authority on the ground. Bangladesh should condition cross‑border trade, humanitarian access, and political engagement with the Arakan Army on measurable Rohingya benchmarks—freedom of movement, land restitution, an end to forced recruitment, international monitoring, and a pathway to citizenship. Dhaka should also urge Myanmar’s government, ASEAN, China, India, Gulf states, and Western nations to back a monitored return‑and‑reparations mechanism. For too long, ports, pipelines, and trade corridors have been labeled “strategic,” while the Rohingya remain confined to humanitarian assistance.

Stakeholders all seek something from Myanmar, and the Rohingya must finally be included in the equation.

The viability of these efforts hinges on the camps’ stability; currently, about 95 % of Rohingya refugees are moderately to highly vulnerable and depend almost entirely on humanitarian aid. The UN’s 2026 response plan, scaled back to $710.5 million—a 26 % reduction from the prior year—calls for support that is increasingly scarce. In April, the World Food Programme cut assistance for roughly two‑thirds of refugees under a tiered system, leaving about 17 % receiving just $7 per person per month.

Donors who celebrate the verdict must also fund the long wait for return. The Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, which supported The Gambia’s case, and Gulf donors bear particular responsibility. Western governments should reverse funding cuts, while lenders and donors should assist Bangladeshi host communities. Underfunded camps foster trafficking, exploitation, and perilous sea journeys to Malaysia and Indonesia; a judgment promising return is meaningless if refugees cannot survive the interim.

Reparations now carry legal force, transcending mere moral appeal. Property claims should be documented, land restored where feasible, and compensation provided where restitution is impossible. While aid pledges survival, reparations demand accountability for the wrong done and oblige parties to repair the harm.

The verdict is historic. The ensuing test is straightforward: can the Rohingya return home as citizens, reclaim land, receive compensation, and raise families outside refugee camps?

The court has established the facts; now justice must deliver them to the Rohingya.

The views expressed in this article are the author’s own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera’s editorial stance.

Source link

Exit mobile version