Experts have warned that Victoria’s electricity supply will be at risk when a major power station shuts in 2028, and neither major party is offering a plan to manage the fallout at this month’s state election.
All parties accept that the giant Yallourn coal plant, which has powered the Latrobe Valley since the 1970s and provides a fifth of Victoria’s electricity, has reached the end of its working life and will close in less than two years. Analysts say, however, that the parties competing to govern the state have failed to properly explain how they would make up the shortfall the closure will leave.
Victoria’s challenge is compounded by rising electricity demand from datacentres and from the electrification of buildings, homes and vehicles. Experts are particularly critical of the Coalition, which is favoured to win under Liberal leader Jess Wilson, because it has promised to halt work on new transmission lines. These high-voltage links are needed to connect new wind and solar farms to the grid and to allow Victoria to import power from neighbouring states.
Tim Baxter, of consultancy Naru Research, says there is no “time for a culture war on energy in Victoria”, warning that poor decisions made now would be “devastating” for the state’s economy and would expose households and businesses to bill shocks.
He says cheap gas helped underpin Victoria’s prosperity in decades past, but that it is running out quickly, with offshore supply from Bass Strait in steep decline. There is no evidence the state has substantial gas reserves elsewhere to take its place. According to Baxter, this has helped drive a 62% rise in gas prices over five years, while electricity bills have climbed 18%.
Because Victorians depend on gas more heavily than people in other states, Baxter says this makes it even more urgent for households to switch from gas to renewable energy. “Every windfarm, solar farm and battery that comes online before 2028 reduces how much expensive gas Victoria has to burn when Yallourn goes. That makes speeding up the build-out the single best way to protect households from higher bills,” he says.
What are Labor and the Coalition promising?
Victoria already has the lowest wholesale electricity prices on the east coast, but households still rely heavily on expensive gas. Under either party, energy bills are likely to rise, according to a government briefing reported in the Herald Sun.
The Coalition says it would scrap VNI West, the transmission line linking Victoria to New South Wales, and pause work on the Western Renewables Link between Melbourne and the state’s west. In their place, it would carry out a “short, sharp and independent” review of the state’s transmission plan to consider alternatives, such as solar panels on commercial and industrial rooftops.
The party has also pledged to “throw open the doors to gas exploration”, reverse Labor’s policy of requiring new homes to be all-electric, and tender for new firming capacity through an Energy Security Requirement modelled on schemes in NSW and South Australia. It does not plan to change the state’s emissions reduction targets, which require greenhouse gas emissions to fall to 75%–80% below 2005 levels by 2035 and reach net zero by 2045, but it has not explained how it would meet them.
Labor says it would keep expanding the power grid, help households switch from gas to electricity for heating and cooking, and continue backing the development of offshore windfarms. The Carroll government is also reviewing the Western Renewables Link. It has recently cancelled a renewable energy zone, approved two gas developments (one of which has since gone into administration) and announced $7.5m to kickstart a “renewable gas industry”.
Stephanie Bashir, chief executive of Nexa Advisory, says new transmission is essential for developing renewable energy and for importing power across state borders when demand peaks, such as during heatwaves. “This is not the time to be cancelling any of the projects in the pipeline,” she says. “This is the time where we put our foot on the accelerator and go hard.”
Jono La Nauze, chief executive of Environment Victoria, says the Coalition’s plan, which includes reviving a policy from the former Baillieu-Napthine Coalition government banning wind turbines within 2km of homes, is “the greatest swindle ever attempted on Victorian voters”.
“The Coalition are promising to stop all the things that are necessary to replace our coal and gas generation. They’ve got some quick slogans for how they’re going to instead rely on gas, with absolutely no substance,” he says.
Analysts say, however, that Labor is not building energy infrastructure quickly enough either.
Oliver Nunn, managing director of consultancy Endgame Analytics, says the absence of an adequate plan to prevent an energy shortfall means that “whoever wins [the election], we lose”.
“You can see demand for electricity pulling up rapidly in Victoria, 5% year-on-year growth,” Nunn says. “Coal’s going out, and we just do not have, at this point, a really viable plan.”
In its 12 years in government, Labor has overseen a surge in renewable energy’s share of Victoria’s electricity from 10% to 44% and the closure of the large Hazelwood coal-fired power station. Windfarm numbers have grown from 14 to 44, and large-scale solar farms from two to 57. Labor also ended the state’s moratorium on conventional gas exploration in 2021.
The state’s auditor general, however, says both VNI West and the Western Renewables Link are running behind schedule and are unlikely to be finished before Yallourn is due to close.
Recent efforts to speed up delivery by legislating for compulsory land acquisition ahead of environmental approvals have proved unpopular in regional communities. Labor says the changes were needed to reduce delays and give landowners greater certainty. In a controversial move, the government also passed laws allowing VicGrid and its contractors to enter private land without the owner’s consent as a last resort, so that essential works can proceed.
“Every time the government seems to hit a hurdle, what they’ve done is not gone back and reassessed the engagement and tried to improve it, what they’ve done is changed legislation to give them broader powers,” says Ryan Milgate, president of the Victorian Farmers Federation.
Shadow energy minister David Davis has branded the laws Labor’s “double bazooka powers” and says the Coalition would scrap them and restore landholders’ rights of appeal.
Bashir of Nexa, however, says energy policy should not be “a political football”.
“We do need to back the replacement generation. We can’t do any more reviews; we’ve just got to get on with it.”
Also Read
- Displaced Palestinians Rally as Israel Expands Its Demolition Drive in Gaza
- Sanrio, Creator of Hello Kitty, Launches Gaming Initiative to Expand Global Presence
- Federal Agents Arrest Two Passengers on Seattle Jet Bridge, Halting Flight and Drawing Outcry
- Bondi Hero Ahmed Al Ahmed, One Year Later: Scars, Courage and a Call for Unity


