Baseball’s hot stove is firing up as clubs race to improve their rosters ahead of the collective bargaining agreement’s Dec. 1 expiration.
The biggest names on this winter’s market — including two-time Cy Young Award winner Tarik Skubal and Japanese slugger Teruaki Sato — remain unsigned, and more stars are sure to follow. As deals get done, we’re evaluating the most notable signings and what they mean for the teams involved.
Contract: Three years, $52.5 million
Grade: C+
Breaking Down This Deal: Chicago needed to steady a rotation that ranked at the bottom of the league in innings pitched by starters last season. May adds depth as a high-ceiling mid-rotation option, but his injury background and inconsistency are real concerns for a club that desperately needs durability and dependability. His 145 innings spread between the Cardinals and Brewers last year were a career best.

Dustin May was a midseason pick for the Brewers on their way to the World Series. (Photo by Michael Reaves/Getty Images)
He flashed that upside with a complete-game shutout against the Padres on June 15, and Milwaukee — the eventual World Series champion — valued his tools enough to make him its centerpiece pitching acquisition at the deadline after he posted a 4.38 ERA over 22 starts in St. Louis. The second half told a different story: May ran up a 5.65 ERA in 10 regular-season starts with the Brewers and a 5.73 mark across five playoff appearances.
There is reason to believe the 29-year-old’s best is still ahead, given his 96.9 mph fastball, the extension he generates from his 6-foot-6 frame, and above-average strikeout and walk rates alongside generally strong stuff. Still, this is a meaningful commitment for a pitcher with that production level, and I had expected the White Sox to aim higher on the starting-pitching market to address their most pressing need. That may yet happen. – Kavner
Contract: Four years, $58 million
Grade: B
Breaking Down This Deal: Never count anyone out. Two years ago, Bauers was weighing retirement. Now look at him. Of the eight players extended the one-year, $23.15 million qualifying offer, he appeared the most likely to take it; another season like this one would only deepen teams’ faith in his breakout and set him up for an even bigger payday in 2028. Instead, Boston moved aggressively in its search for power, and the 31-year-old chose long-term security. The Red Sox are wagering that he builds on a career year in Milwaukee — one in which he ranked seventh in MLB in wRC+, tied for 10th in OPS, and delivered when the stakes were highest in October.

Jake Bauers’ postseason performances boosted his free agent stock. (Katelyn Mulcahy/MLB Photos via Getty Images)
The risk is plain. Entering 2026, the journeyman carried a career .672 OPS and had never surpassed 12 homers in a season. Bauers will cost Boston its second- and fifth-highest Draft picks, and the fit is far from clean: Willson Contreras was the club’s best hitter this year, and the two figure to divide first base and DH duties, leaving even fewer opportunities for a surplus of Red Sox outfielders that could force a trade.
But a team that finished 26th in home runs and 21st in walks found a bat that addresses both areas, and the underlying numbers indicate the breakout was genuine. If Bauers replicates last season for the next four years, a $14.5 million average annual value will look like a bargain. — Kavner
Contract: Three years, $35 million
Grade: B-
Breaking Down This Deal: Atlanta’s most obvious need is starting pitching, but the Braves still had bullpen work to do with closer Raisel Iglesias reaching free agency. Phillips, one of the game’s premier relievers when healthy over the past six seasons with the Dodgers, should help fill that gap. Locking him up early also buys the club flexibility: they can pursue another closer and pair him with Phillips, Robert Suarez or Dylan Lee in high-leverage spots, or hand the ninth to one of that trio while focusing on their bigger holes up the rotation and at shortstop. It also opens the door to deciding how best to use versatile 21-year-old Didier Fuentes.

A high-leverage arm is heading to Atlanta. (Photo by Todd Kirkland/Getty Images)
For Phillips, the contract is a homecoming. The 32-year-old was drafted by Atlanta in 2015 and debuted with the club in 2018 before being traded to Baltimore. Released in 2021, he signed a minor-league deal with the Rays, was designated for assignment, and was claimed by the Dodgers, where he rebuilt his career — a 2.36 ERA with 254 strikeouts and 46 saves across 221 innings over the last six seasons.
He returned from Tommy John surgery last year with the highest average four-seam velocity of his career. He was barreled more often than ever, and combined with career highs in fly-ball rate and a low in ground-ball rate, he allowed five homers in 26 innings. Yet he struck out 33 batters against just six walks, and his stuff improved as the season went on: over the final two months, Phillips posted a 2.41 ERA with 24 strikeouts and four walks in 18.2 innings, then made five scoreless postseason appearances. It is a rich price for a reliever who may not close and a pitcher who has thrown only 86.1 regular-season innings over three seasons. But if he stays healthy, Phillips should keep Atlanta’s bullpen among its strengths. — Kavner

