Why the Yankees’ “Noise” Defense Misses the Point

New York finished with 93 victories, the second-highest total in the American League, and advanced through one playoff round. It was another season of sustained success: the team reached the postseason for the ninth time in ten years and the 27th time over the last 32 years.

Yet instead of praise, the franchise is facing a level of criticism usually reserved for far worse campaigns—some even drawing unfavorable comparisons to the Mets.

It has become an autumn ritual. Whenever the Yankees fall short of a championship, leadership is pilloried as incompetent, their long history of consistent excellence dismissed as irrelevant.

In response, the organization labels the backlash “noise”—uninformed and malicious. Undeniably, the modern outrage economy rewards inflammatory takes far more than thoughtful analysis, but that does not erase every legitimate concern.

Source link