Peter Hook has ruled out a New Order reunion, stating that only a payday comparable to the reported Oasis reunion sum could persuade him to reconsider. The bassist made the remarks while attending the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame ceremony, where Joy Division and New Order were inducted together.
Hook appeared at the event on Saturday, November 14, without any of his former bandmates. He performed “Love Will Tear Us Apart” and “Bizarre Love Triangle” alongside Deftones and Chvrches. Stephen Morris and Gillian Gilbert were absent due to health reasons, with Gilbert currently battling cancer; Bernard Sumner also did not attend.
Hook played bass for Joy Division until the band evolved into New Order following Ian Curtis’s death in 1980. He departed New Order in 2007, sparking years of legal disputes and public exchanges. Citing longstanding tensions and dissatisfaction with the group’s creative direction, Hook left as the remaining members continued touring and recording without him. Since then, Peter Hook & The Light has spent years performing material from both bands’ catalogs.
In a previous interview with York Calling, Hook detailed financial grievances, claiming he receives “one penny for every pound” the group earns in royalties despite his significant contributions, which he called “the utmost treachery.” He also accused his former bandmates of “conning their fans” by performing without him and said he would “never forgive them.”
During his Rock Hall acceptance speech, Hook thanked fans but made only passing reference to his former bandmates. “I’m on my own, but I’m not alone,” he said. “I want to thank the fans for all their wonderful and priceless efforts in making this happen and putting me here tonight. This award is for them.” He added, “For me, it’s been a wild 50 years. I’ve been happy, I’ve been mad, I’ve been heartbroken in equal measures, but I’m still fucking here. Music is eternal, fans are eternal, and we are eternally grateful.”
Speaking to the press, Hook dismissed any prospect of a reunion. “Why not? Because of what they did to me, I’ll never forgive them. And for what they did to me and my family, I’ll never forgive them. Simple as that,” he said.
He did reference the reported financial success of Oasis’s “Live ’25” reunion, quipping: “Unless someone offers us $200 million, then I’ll do what Oasis did!” Oasis was also part of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame’s 2025 class, alongside Phil Collins, Billy Idol, Wu-Tang Clan, and others.
The remarks echo comments Hook made to Rolling Stone earlier this year, when he suggested a reunion might occur only if Bernard Sumner apologized for the years-long legal battle that cost Hook a substantial portion of his earnings. “You never know,” Hook said at the time.
Hook previously told NME that the remaining members had done little to advocate for the band’s Rock Hall induction. He also expressed frustration that neither the band nor the Rolling Stone UK Awards notified him before Bernard Sumner accepted an Icon Award at the 2025 ceremony, describing the oversight as “a bit of a pisser.” Still, Hook said he welcomed the Rock Hall honor.
“I think it’s fantastic,” Hook said. “Anyone who appreciates your music—whether now or 50 years ago when we started—is absolutely fine by me. Let’s face it, it makes you smile and keeps you going through a very difficult world. It’s fucking fantastic when anyone offers you a compliment like that.” He added that New Order and Joy Division’s social media accounts, which he said are controlled by the other three members, did little to promote the induction.
“If I was going to be really cynical, do you think it was so they didn’t have to meet me? Could that be possible?” he asked.
Trent Reznor of Nine Inch Nails introduced the bands, calling Joy Division and New Order “two of the most influential groups of the last 50 years.” He praised their evolution from Joy Division’s stark post-punk sound to New Order’s pioneering blend of guitar and electronic dance music.
“There are only two types of people in this world,” Reznor said. “Those who already know just how influential Joy Division and New Order are, and those yet to realize how their favorite bands—such as U2, Radiohead, the Cure, the Killers, Nirvana, and Depeche Mode—would sound if Joy Division and New Order had never existed.” Reznor also credited the groups with inspiring him to be “fearless and try something new.”
Also Read
- Mike Mills Reflects on R.E.M.’s ‘Reveal’ at 25: Creative Renewal, Political Conviction, and Why the Band Won’t Reunite
- Laura Brand Addresses Husband’s Absence on Faith Podcast Following Rape Conviction
- Honoring Legends: Key Highlights from the 17th Governors Awards
- The Oak Ridge Boys: 10 Defining Songs That Shaped Their Legacy

