Wednesday, November 18, 2026

In Gidan Dare, a farming settlement beside the BUA Cement plant in northwest Nigeria, residents say wells that once produced water at three or four metres now have to be drilled seventy metres or more before anything is found.

They describe mud homes splitting and giving way under the vibration of constant heavy truck traffic, and plant noise that still keeps them awake close to midnight. The International Finance Corporation (IFC) states that it confirmed “broad community support” for the expansion during a site visit in August 2022. Yet none of the community leaders I spoke with can recall being consulted before BUA extended its operations onto land their families had farmed for generations.

I head the Quest for Growth and Development Foundation in Nigeria, where I work with five communities around the plant, one of which was resettled to make way for the expansion. Their experience puts a human face on the global climate crisis that governments are debating at COP31. Projects like this one, backed by institutions such as IFC, almost never figure in that debate.

Once the new production lines are running, the plant will release roughly 4.1 million tonnes of CO₂ a year, with 2.9 million tonnes attributable to the expansion. IFC approved $210 million for that expansion and rated it Category A, its highest tier of environmental and social risk. That poses a direct question for the World Bank’s Board of Executive Directors: do IFC’s climate commitments mean what they appear to say?

IFC’s own file suggests they do not. The project sets no emissions reduction target, and it requires no independent verification of the figures cited, either before approval or at any point since. What the file does contain is a promise: IFC’s Climate Advisory arm “will support BUA integrate low-carbon solutions in the existing and new facilities, to further reduce its carbon footprint.” The central climate claim therefore rests on advisory work that may happen later, rather than on measurable commitments that anyone outside the institution can test.

For the people living beside the plant, the same accountability gap persists. IFC’s records state that they were consulted; they say otherwise. BUA says it supports its host communities through health care, scholarships and donations. Those contributions matter, but they cannot replace consultation before a high-risk project is approved.

This is not an isolated failure at a single site. It is what IFC’s published climate methodology allows for a project counted as aligned with the Paris Agreement. In practice, a promise is enough to secure the label, while verification is optional. For a high-risk cement plant expansion in one of the hardest industrial sectors on earth to decarbonise, that gap is not a technicality. It is the whole problem.

Cleaner cement is already financeable. IFC, for example, has funded a calcined clay cement plant in Burkina Faso. For every cement investment, IFC should require a transparent analysis of alternatives showing why lower-carbon production options are, or are not, feasible before approval is granted. None of this depends on the outcome of the Independent Evaluation Group’s ongoing review of the World Bank Group’s Climate Change Action Plan, a review requested by the Bank’s own board this year and not yet published. The evidence is already in IFC’s file on this project, in its own methodology, and in what residents on the ground have been reporting for years.

IFC is rewriting its Sustainability Framework, the environmental and social rulebook for every project it funds, and a first draft is expected in the coming weeks. Executive Directors should insist on four changes to close the gap this file exposes: publish a measured emissions baseline before the board votes, rather than an advisory pledge to produce one later; require independent verification of climate and community consultation claims before a project is labelled climate-aligned; make an independent audit against a credible pathway, such as the IEA Cement Roadmap, a condition of financing; and require a completed analysis of lower-carbon alternatives before approval.

I am not asking the Executive Directors to accept the word of Nigerian farmers alone. I am asking them to close these gaps in the revision of the Sustainability Framework. Climate barely featured when the World Bank and its member governments met this October. That is precisely the problem: when accountability lapses, IFC does not absorb the cost. Families in communities like Gidan Dare do, and they have the least capacity to adapt. The board does not need to wait for climate to return to the agenda. It needs a rule that makes climate commitments binding and checkable, rather than a pledge to be settled at some later date. Climate finance should be able to prove what it promises.

Source link

Exit mobile version