CMS Proposes Trimming Medicare Advantage Star Ratings to 15 Measures and Raising the Bar for Top Scores[/TITLE>
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services has proposed narrowing Medicare Advantage star ratings to 15 measures centered on clinical outcomes and patient experience, while adjusting the scoring methodology to make the highest ratings more difficult to achieve, according to the agency’s Nov. 20 announcement of the proposed rule. Because bonus payments are tied to the stars, a reduction in top ratings could translate into less money for the supplemental benefits plans offer.
The changes are part of a proposed rule governing contract year 2028. The proposal is not final and will remain open for public comment for 60 days after it appears in the Federal Register.
For the more than 35 million Americans enrolled in Medicare Advantage, the proposal leaves 2027 coverage unchanged. It could, however, influence which plans earn bonuses later in the decade—and the dental, vision, and reduced copays those bonuses help support.
A Shorter List of Measures and a Higher Threshold
Star ratings range from 1 to 5 and are among the first details seniors review when comparing plans. Medicare Advantage plans that include drug coverage are currently assessed on up to 43 measures, according to the CMS fact sheet for the 2027 final rule.
The proposed rule would retain select process measures only in high-priority areas where performance has lagged. CMS did not identify the 15 measures or the revised cutoffs in its announcement, making it impossible at this stage to determine which plans might lose stars.
Plans rated 4 stars or higher qualify for quality bonus payments, and higher ratings also increase the rebates plans use to fund supplemental benefits. Raising the bar for top ratings would likely reduce bonus spending, though CMS did not release cost estimates in its announcement.
The approach marks a departure from last year’s rulemaking. The 2027 final rule eliminated 11 measures, most of them focused on administrative processes, and CMS’s own regulatory analysis estimated that the star ratings changes would shift about $18.5 billion to plans over 10 years, according to a Reed Smith analysis of the rule.
Lawsuits Already Testing the Ratings
The proposal arrives as insurers contest the current system in court. At least 16 insurers have sued CMS over their 2027 star ratings, arguing that the agency applied measures never established through notice-and-comment rulemaking. Collectively, they estimate more than $4.1 billion in lost bonuses, Becker’s Hospital Review reported.
MedicalDaily previously reported that UnitedHealth, the largest Medicare Advantage insurer, has joined the litigation. No court has ruled on the 2027 claims.
A rule established through formal rulemaking could address part of the insurers’ complaint, since measures set through notice and comment are more difficult to challenge. Supporters of stricter ratings contend that the bonus program disburses payments broadly without clearly improving care. Insurers counter that stable, predictable ratings enable them to invest in quality.
Food Benefits, Networks, and a New Model
The rule extends beyond star ratings. Food and beverage benefits would be required to cover whole, nutrient-dense foods aligned with the 2025–2030 Dietary Guidelines for Americans. The food and produce benefit for chronically ill enrollees was used nearly 40 million times in 2025, according to CMS.
Certain high-calorie nutrition drinks that fail to meet the standard could still be covered when a provider recommends them for a documented medical need. “Medicare food benefits should pay for nutritious food that helps people improve their health and manage chronic disease,” said HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr.
New plans would demonstrate compliance with network adequacy standards during their first year of operation rather than during the application process. Three behavioral health specialty types—clinical psychology, clinical social work, and outpatient behavioral health—would be consolidated into a single category, and plans could receive greater credit for telehealth in meeting network requirements.
These network changes carry implications for families. A combined behavioral health category could make it easier for a plan to satisfy standards on paper, so enrollees may wish to confirm that a specific therapist or psychiatrist is in network before enrolling. The same caution applies to telehealth: a plan that counts virtual visits toward its network may still offer few in-person options nearby.
CMS also proposed ADVaNCE MA, a mandatory 10-year model beginning in 2029 in select states. The model would allow plans to target certain supplemental benefits to low-income enrollees, tie a portion of payment to quality, and test a new risk adjustment method.
The proposal would additionally introduce plan options in markets with dual eligible special needs plans, which serve individuals enrolled in both Medicare and Medicaid. “People with Medicare should be able to choose coverage based on what matters most to them,” said CMS Administrator Dr. Mehmet Oz.
What the Choices Mean for Seniors and Caregivers
Nothing in the proposal alters plans for 2027, and Medicare open enrollment still closes Dec. 7. Seniors comparing plans can use star ratings as one guide, alongside doctor and hospital networks, drug coverage, and total annual costs.
The Medicare Plan Finder tool displays individual measure scores, which may carry more weight for a given person than the overall rating. Caregivers assisting a parent in choosing a plan can verify whether the plan’s extras—such as dental coverage or a food card—are benefits the parent would actually use.
Free, unbiased assistance is available through each state’s State Health Insurance Assistance Program and at 1-800-MEDICARE. People already enrolled in Medicare Advantage may make one plan change between Jan. 1 and March 31.
The public will be able to comment once the rule is published. MedicalDaily will report the comment deadline, the 15 measures once CMS releases them, and any final rule.
Key Questions Answered
What did CMS propose? Reducing Medicare Advantage star ratings to 15 measures and revising the scoring method to make high ratings harder to attain.
Is the rule final? No. It is a proposal open for 60 days of public comment following Federal Register publication.
Will my 2027 plan change? No. Benefits and ratings for 2027 are already set.
Why do star ratings matter? Plans with 4 or more stars earn bonuses that help fund supplemental benefits such as dental coverage and lower copays.
What else does the proposal include? Stricter food benefit standards, network adequacy changes, and a new 10-year Medicare Advantage model starting in 2029.
When does open enrollment end? Dec. 7, 2026.
Also Read
- Do GLP-1 Drugs Mask or Fuel Disordered Eating?[/TITLE>
- FDA Approves Promega’s OncoMate Test as a Companion Diagnostic for Keytruda in MSI-High Solid Tumors
- Metformin Shows Promise in Long COVID Management; Lp(a) Reduction Emerges as Key Cardiovascular Strategy
- Illicit cigarettes at Sydney “clean beauty” launch prompt health investigation


