U.S. Soccer confirmed Mauricio Pochettino’s departure for Manchester United early Friday, a move that surprised few. The federation announced that Steve Cherundolo, head coach of the U-23 men’s national team, would oversee the December 13 friendly against Jamaica—a match falling outside the FIFA international window—while the search for a permanent replacement begins immediately. CEO J.T. Batson and COO Dan Helfrich will spearhead the process alongside the federation’s soccer leadership group, including assistant sporting director Oguchi Onyewu. Notably, the press release revealed a distinctive addition to the committee: U.S. women’s national team head coach Emma Hayes.
Collaboration between men’s and women’s national team setups is rare at the federation level, largely because the programs operate on separate calendars with distinct staffing structures. While U.S. Soccer frequently promotes a unified philosophy across its national teams, the formal inclusion of a senior women’s head coach in the search for a men’s counterpart is unprecedented. In this specific context, however, the decision is entirely logical.
Hayes brings two decades of coaching experience across two continents, making her presence on the soccer leadership team a natural fit. Widely regarded as one of the sport’s preeminent tacticians, she is arguably the most critical asset on U.S. Soccer’s payroll. Her insight will be indispensable as the federation seeks a compelling successor to Pochettino, whose initial appointment two years ago generated significant buzz. Hayes’ perspective adds a crucial layer of intrigue to the USMNT’s next chapter.
Hayes’ Crucial Tactical Insights
Historically, U.S. Soccer has rarely prioritized a specific playing philosophy when hiring men’s national team coaches. A review of the full-time appointees this century—Bruce Arena, Bob Bradley, Jürgen Klinsmann, Gregg Berhalter, and Pochettino—reveals a common thread: each was brought in to engineer a cultural reset. Pochettino’s successor, however, faces a different mandate. The incoming coach will inherit a squad with an established playing identity, a balanced blend of veterans and emerging talent, and a generous runway before the next World Cup. Consequently, the role will be defined largely by continuity, albeit with room for the new manager to imprint their own tactical nuances.
This is precisely where Hayes’ expertise becomes pivotal, complementing Onyewu’s playing background. Her tactical acumen qualifies her as well as anyone within the federation to define the stylistic profile required for the next USMNT coach, particularly with continuity as a guiding principle. While Pochettino’s tenure produced mixed results, his high-intensity, attack-oriented approach aligned well with the current player pool—a fit that persists today. Hayes, a pragmatic tactician who has consistently championed proactive, attacking football at both Chelsea and with the USWNT, is exceptionally positioned to evaluate which candidates best match the roster they will oversee for the next cycle.
The necessity for such discernment is heightened by a shallow market for elite, universally recognized candidates. Pep Guardiola, currently on sabbatical after a decade at Manchester City, represents an obvious aspirational target, though his interest remains speculative at best. Should Guardiola decline, the pool of globally renowned names shrinks rapidly, yet it does not eliminate viable options. The committee must then operate strategically—curating a robust shortlist and rigorously vetting candidates through interviews—with Hayes providing a critical analytical voice throughout.
Familiarity With the Demands of the Job
Although the demands of the USMNT and USWNT head coaching roles differ significantly, the shared experience of occupying such a singular position offers inherent value. Coaches in these roles are frequently viewed as the ultimate arbiters of their program’s success. Hayes can also articulate the distinct rhythm of international management—a stark contrast to the daily grind of club football. “Everyone is aware of the major differences between coaching at the club level and international level, and the main difference is just time on the field and time with your players,” Hayes told CBS Sports earlier this year. “Every international coach would love to have more time with their team, but that’s not the nature of the international calendar… it’s almost like we are grandparents. We get to see the players for a week or so and then we send them back to their parents, which is their clubs.”
Beyond tactical fluency, Hayes embodies the ambitious trajectory U.S. Soccer has pursued in recent years, mirroring the statement made by Pochettino’s hiring. She was recruited on the strength of a decorated tenure at Chelsea, where she claimed eight league titles and seven domestic cups. She validated that pedigree immediately with the USWNT, capturing Olympic gold in Paris just two months into her tenure. The federation harbors equally lofty aspirations for the men’s program, albeit on a longer timeline. Targets include a first World Cup quarterfinal appearance since 2002 and an historic Olympic medal on home soil in Los Angeles in 2028. Few within the organization possess Hayes’ firsthand experience navigating the intangibles required to reach such heights—a primary factor in her original hiring.
Furthermore, Hayes occupies a unique vantage point regarding the specific demands of the USMNT role. She combines a deep, two-decade understanding of the American soccer landscape—where her coaching career began—with the credibility forged in her native England. This dual perspective allows her to bridge the gap between an insider’s institutional knowledge and an outsider’s elite expertise. No current candidate for the USMNT job possesses this exact hybrid profile; the federation will likely have to prioritize one background over the other. Hayes’ ability to weigh the merits of each approach makes her an indispensable guide in navigating that decision.
The List of Contacts
Hayes’ tactical and cultural insights alone render her an invaluable sounding board, but she offers an additional asset unmatched within the federation: a direct line to the sport’s most prominent coaching figures.
During her transformative 12-year reign at Chelsea, Hayes evolved into one of the most respected figures in English football, becoming the first woman to receive the Football Writers’ Association Tribute Award in 2024 prior to her Stateside move. She has cultivated deep relationships across the men’s game; notably, Sir Alex Ferguson reportedly contacts her “from time to time.” Her network extends to active managers previously linked to the USMNT vacancy. In her 2024 memoir, A Completely Different Game, Hayes revealed that Guardiola and Jürgen Klopp sent lengthy, emotional messages of support following her emergency hysterectomy in 2022, as did Graham Potter and David Moyes.
Such a network is a strategic asset, as evidenced by former sporting director Matt Crocker’s tenure. Crocker’s most significant achievements—hiring both Hayes and Pochettino—were facilitated by pre-existing relationships, notably his prior work with Pochettino at Southampton. While Hayes’ value transcends her contact list, U.S. Soccer would be remiss not to leverage the access and credibility her relationships provide throughout this critical search.
Also Read
- IPL 2027 Auction: Three Kolkata Knight Riders Players Worth Parting Ways With
- Steelers Guard Mason McCormick Diagnosed With Dislocated Ankle, Playoff Return Possible
- India vs New Zealand: Morne Morkel Explains Why Doing The ‘Dirty Job’ Could Decide Wellington Test
- Midseason Honors: MVP, Biggest Bust, and Additional Awards from the Jets’ Disappointing Campaign
