NEW YORK — Bettors linked to Emmanuel Clase wagered thousands of dollars on specific pitches ahead of two Cleveland Guardians games in June 2025, without knowing the batter or whether the starting pitcher would still be on the mound, according to witness testimony Monday in the federal gambling trial of Clase and Luis Ortiz.
Joshua Mehta, director of legal and regulatory affairs for FanDuel, testified that accounts registered to individuals linked to Clase placed bets on first pitches in Guardians games on June 15, 2025, against the Seattle Mariners, and June 27, 2025, against the St. Louis Cardinals. Ortiz started both games.
Mehta testified that FanDuel took in a number of wagers on whether the first pitch in the bottom of the third inning of the Mariners-Guardians game would be called a ball or result in a hit batsman. He said several bets were placed by an account registered to Enoc Pena, who, according to government witness testimony, was a close associate of Clase. Pena’s bets on that pitch against the Mariners won approximately $12,000 when Ortiz threw a ball outside the strike zone.
Mehta said some of the same accounts again placed substantial bets on the Guardians’ first pitch in the top of the third inning being a ball or a hit batsman against the Cardinals. Ortiz’s first pitch of the inning was outside the strike zone.
Mehta said at least five accounts that bet on the Ortiz pitches were suspended in June 2025, noting that using inside information to bet violates the sportsbook’s terms of service.
Ortiz was placed on nondisciplinary leave by Major League Baseball on July 3, 2025. About four weeks later, Clase was also placed on leave by MLB.
Both pitchers have pleaded not guilty to conspiracy charges related to wire fraud, sports bribery, honest services and money laundering.
Jenner Olivo, a government cooperating witness, testified earlier Monday that he used information he received from Pena to win bets on select Clase pitches during the 2023, 2024 and 2025 baseball seasons. The government alleges that bettors won at least $400,000 wagering on the result and speed of at least 18 Clase pitches.
At the end of Monday’s session, Mehta also testified that a FanDuel account registered to Clase was opened in May 2023. The only bets shown as placed on the account were on the NBA. It is not against MLB rules for players to bet on sports other than baseball.

