Paris, France – Six years ago, Michel Zecler was beaten by three police officers inside his Parisian music studio.
Surveillance footage shows the officers forcing Zecler, who is Black, into the studio and assaulting him until fellow musicians intervened on November 21, 2020.
Aurelien Lapersonne, Pierre Plantier and Philippe Tondeux are accused of striking the music producer 29 times in the space of four minutes, then striking him six more times in the face after he was already handcuffed.
A verdict is expected on Friday.
The case ignited a national reckoning over police brutality in France and drew widespread public attention. In the aftermath, football star Kylian Mbappe shared an image of a badly injured Zecler, blood streaming down his face, captioned: “Unbearable video. Unacceptable violence.”
The three officers also stand accused of forging a public document.
During the assault, the officers allegedly hurled racist remarks at Zecler. All three signed a falsified police report claiming that Zecler had struck the officers—an account flatly contradicted by the surveillance footage.
“It’s pretty obvious that this case is about institutional racism, systemic discrimination and police violence. Everything is connected. Not only are we dealing with police violence against a Black man, but that’s on top of attempting to conceal evidence and falsify a report,” Rim-Sarah Alouane, a legal scholar and associate researcher in public law at the University of Toulouse Capitole, told Al Jazeera. “When these reports are falsified, we’re questioning the integrity of the entire system.”
Prosecutors have requested a permanent dismissal from the force for all three officers, alongside prison terms.
The prosecution called for six years without parole for Lapersonne, the officer who initiated the identity check and submitted the falsified report, a five-year sentence for Tondeux, the trio’s leader and the most experienced officer present, and four years for Plantier.
“There is no room for a symbolic sentence,” a representative of the public prosecutor’s office said. “We are talking about crimes, violence and racial slurs. About a complete lack of control over what was done and an absolute determination to get away with it in the end.”
A series of court rulings has exposed systemic discrimination within France’s police force.
Last year, the European Court of Human Rights condemned France for the racial profiling of Karim Touil, a young French national of North African origin who was stopped by police three times in the span of 10 days in November and December 2011.
In October 2023, France’s highest court acknowledged that racial profiling occurs during police identity checks but stopped short of ordering authorities to take the “necessary measures to end this longstanding, abusive practice,” according to Human Rights Watch.
In 2021, the French government was found guilty of “gross negligence” over the identity check of three high school students at the Gare du Nord station in Paris.
Although concerns about police violence in France are far from new, Alouane said this trial carries particular weight because of the surveillance footage and the alleged cover-up.
“This trial brings to light those issues that human rights organisations have been documenting for years. It gives an illustration, through a proper case, about the use of force and systemic violence that we’ve known about for years,” she said. “If there was no footage, we would not be here today. The police would have gotten away with it.”
Lapersonne, who authored the report, initially claimed that Zecler had attacked the officers and “struck out with his arms and legs.” When the presiding judge asked whether he had “made that up,” Lapersonne replied, “Absolutely.” His initial report also omitted any mention of the blows the officers landed on Zecler.
“I deliberately omitted them. I think out of fear. It was stupid of me,” Lapersonne told the judge.
For Alouane, the case laid bare the mechanics of systemic police violence in France.
“The falsified documents aspect is crucial to illustrate why this case advanced and the public attention it received. In this case, the footage directly contradicted the police’s claims. The cops knew they did something wrong,” she said. “This is a serious accusation and not an isolated incident.”
The trial unfolds as France’s Senate weighs a contentious bill that would presume police officers and gendarmes acted in self-defence when using firearms in the line of duty, shifting the burden of proof onto the complainant. Critics have branded the proposal a “licence to kill.” The National Assembly approved the measure in July.
“It’s a very dangerous piece of legislation. It’s liberticide. It would create a sense of impunity amongst police officers—which already exists, but this would strengthen that. It would undermine investigations and make access to the justice system even more difficult for victims and their families,” Alouane said. “It raises serious issues regarding equality under the law because it puts a presumption of innocence in favour of people because of their profession as cops.”
Such legislation, she warned, could have prevented cases like Zecler’s from ever reaching a courtroom.
“If this proposal were in place, we would not have this case. It would have been dismissed today,” she said.
French police are also facing scrutiny over their tactics during recent student protests. A 15-year-old lost a hand to a police stun grenade, and an officer fired a tear gas canister at close range, shattering a 14-year-old’s jaw and several teeth.

