Greb Outworks Walker in Grueling 1925 Polo Grounds Title Defense

The contest served as the centerpiece of a benefit for the Italian Hospital Fund, sharing a card with Harry Wills versus Charley Weinert before a crowd of tens of thousands that generated a gate estimated between $339,000 and $375,000. A toe injury had forced Walker to postpone the original June 19 date, drawing skepticism from reporters who questioned the severity of the ailment. Any doubts about Walker’s resolve vanished once the opening bell rang.

The challenger immediately targeted Greb’s midsection with heavy hooks, attempting to drag the fight into a phone-booth brawl. Greb countered with the frenetic, angular assault that earned him the “Pittsburgh Windmill” moniker, unleashing punches from every conceivable angle while employing every tactic—legal and otherwise—at his disposal.

The second round evolved into an early referendum on control. Walker’s compact power posed a constant threat whenever he carved out space, but Greb refused to let him breathe, smothering the younger champion, countering over his shots, and forcing him to navigate a relentless current of leather.

Remarkably, Greb conducted the entire campaign while concealing severe vision loss in one eye, a disability he guarded throughout his career. Contemporary accounts also noted that he battled leg cramps during the early sessions.

As the fight deepened, the champion’s experience and unsustainable work rate began to tilt the scales. Walker continued to thud hard shots to the body, yet Greb dictated the geography and tempo through sheer volume, movement, and physical strength.

The narrative crystallized in a violent 14th round. A right hand from Greb badly dazed Walker, who was then driven toward the ropes and pummeled. Walker later described the sensation as being knocked “ragtime,” moving “like a man walking in a dream.” He survived the onslaught, though he accused Greb of thumbing him in the eye during the sequence.

Walker rallied gamely in the 15th for one final push, but it could not erase the accumulated deficit. Referee Eddie Purdy rendered the decision for Greb after 15 punishing rounds.

Both men bore the marks of war. Walker’s face was a mask of blood and swelling around the eyes; some ringside reports claimed Greb lost teeth in the exchange. The victory retained Greb’s middleweight crown and added another superhuman chapter to a career conducted at a pace that defies modern comprehension.

Tiger Flowers would eventually dethrone Greb, and Walker captured the middleweight title in 1926. Greb died later that same year at age 32 following surgery.

A persistent legend claims the rivals engaged in a “16th round” outside a New York nightclub afterward, with Walker flooring Greb before police intervened. No contemporary newspaper corroborates the story, and members of Greb’s entourage disputed it. The alleged street fight remains folklore; the 15 rounds inside the ropes required no embellishment.

Source link