Thursday, November 19, 2026

American voters have spent this month’s midterm debates on data centres, focusing on who should pay for grid upgrades, who bears water costs, and who gets a say. Southeast Asia, which has quietly become a global overflow market for compute, did not receive that debate. It received press statements.

Worse, the two decisions that will shape Johor’s data-centre future over the next year were not made in Johor, Kuala Lumpur or Singapore. One was made by voters in Ohio and Pennsylvania. The other was made by the US Department of Commerce.

That should concern anyone who cares about how the region is governed, not only how it is invested in.

US policy and voter sentiment

The campaign data was striking. Data-centre-related television advertising cost campaigns more than US$380 million, according to AdImpact. An NBC exit poll found that nearly 80 per cent of respondents opposed new data centres in their neighbourhoods, TechCrunch reported. On election night, Senator Bernie Sanders called for a national moratorium.

The backlash carried a price tag. Wholesale electricity prices near some US data centres have risen by as much as 267 per cent over five years, according to a Bloomberg analysis cited by Fortune.

One can debate whether a moratorium is sensible. I suspect it is not. The point is that Americans debated it publicly and through the ballot. If the incoming Congress makes data centres harder to build at home, capital will not disappear; it will move somewhere quieter.

Southeast Asia’s quiet precedent

The same playbook has appeared before. Singapore’s moratorium between 2019 and 2022 did not eliminate demand; it redirected it across the Causeway. Johor now hosts roughly 80 per cent of Malaysia’s operational data-centre capacity, largely because of that pause.

The growth since then has been extraordinary. Johor had 1,110MW of live IT capacity in 2026 and 8,542MW in the pipeline, according to Knight Frank’s Data Centre Atlas. Malaysia’s energy minister told Parliament in a written reply that data-centre electricity use could rise from 10,544GWh this year to 73,274GWh by 2035, increasing from 7 per cent to 31 per cent of Peninsular Malaysia’s demand.

A sevenfold increase in a decade is more than an industrial policy footnote. It is a change in what the grid is for.

Singapore exported a resource problem to a neighbour, and that neighbour’s residents had no vote on Singapore’s moratorium either. That is the region’s first lesson: data-centre externalities cross borders, but accountability does not.

A credit where it is due

It would be lazy to claim that Malaysia has done nothing. In several respects, it has moved ahead of the US.

Data centres connected above 50kV have paid an ultra-high-voltage tariff since July 2025, and operators must bear grid-upgrade costs under a user-pays approach. Johor stopped approving less efficient Tier 1 and Tier 2 facilities. Data centres in the state pay RM5.33 (about US$1.30) per cubic metre of water, roughly five times a household’s first band. In February, Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim moved to halt new non-AI data centres.

Sceptics also have a fair point on water. Johor’s data centres used about 9.07 million litres a day, or roughly 0.6 per cent of the state’s consumption. Some viral claims blaming data centres for local outages proved incorrect.

So this is not a story of a reckless state. It is a story about how the rules were made.

Policy by announcement is not consent

Consider the sequence. In February, residents of Gelang Patah staged what was described as Malaysia’s first data-centre protest. Residents of Nusa Bayu sent a memorandum to the Menteri Besar’s office requesting greater transparency on power and water. When silt reduced supply to more than 455,000 Johor accounts in late 2025, a deputy minister said data centres had bought water from their own tankers.

The rules tightened after each flashpoint. That is responsive governance, but not public participation. Residents often learn about a hyperscale campus when the dust settles.

The data problem makes it worse. Projections for data-centre water demand in Selangor and Johor reach 389 million litres a day by 2030, far above what operators report using today. Both figures can be accurate, since applications and actual use differ. But when the public cannot tell which number to plan around, distrust fills the gap.

Now Washington holds the pen

Then came 16 November. The US Department of Commerce named Singapore, Malaysia, Thailand and Indonesia among countries posing higher risks of diversion and now requires licences to ship advanced AI chips to them. Data centres anywhere also need a licence to sell large volumes of compute to China-headquartered firms.

Singapore responded by seeking “trusted access”. That will be negotiated between officials, and rightly so. But it means the most consequential variable in the region’s data-centre economy — which chips arrive and who may rent them — is now being set in a US regulatory process. Southeast Asian citizens are two steps removed from it.

Americans voted on whether to host data centres. Southeast Asians are being told, by Americans, on what terms they may host them.

What a ballot looks like without an election

No one needs a referendum for every server hall. But the region can adopt the substance of what US voters demanded without enduring the gridlock.

It could start with disclosure. Facility-level power and water use should be published quarterly, not just state totals. Malaysia’s water-use cap of 1.8 litres per kWh is meaningless to residents who cannot see whether their neighbour meets it.

It should make consultation binding rather than ceremonial. Projects above a threshold should face a public hearing before approval, with power and water impact studies released in advance.

It should share the upside locally. If a campus draws on a district’s river, a share of its tax take should remain in that district.

It should coordinate regionally. The Data Centre Association of Malaysia warned last year that higher tariffs could push investment to Vietnam and Thailand. That is exactly the race to the bottom that an ASEAN baseline on disclosure and water standards would stop. If Johor, Batam and Chonburi compete on who asks the fewest questions, residents everywhere lose.

The vote we are not having

Southeast Asia sold itself as the place where AI infrastructure could be built fast, cheaply and without fuss. That pitch worked. But “without fuss” often means “without asking”.

The US midterms showed what happens when people who live next to the grid finally get asked: they push back hard, sometimes too hard. This region has a chance to ask earlier, and more sensibly.

If it does not, the debate will still happen. It will just happen in Washington, and in the streets of Gelang Patah, rather than somewhere it can be settled.

Source link

Exit mobile version