NEW YORK – The logistical challenges of Sunday’s NWSL semifinal at Icahn Stadium — a compact venue tucked onto an island between Manhattan and Queens — were expected to fade once Gotham FC and the Kansas City Current took the field for one of the league’s showcase fixtures. When the Current’s Croix Bethune broke the deadlock in the 20th minute with a spectacular looping free kick, the narrative shifted: the league would salvage the imperfect setting with a high-caliber contest, or at least deliver a few highlight-reel moments from a match featuring some of the world’s most gifted players.
“I’ve been working on free kicks all year,” Bethune said afterward, the Current’s winter signing vindicated even if validation was hardly necessary, “and a lot more leading into the playoffs so just practice makes perfect.”
Icahn Stadium’s quirks, however, mirrored the match it unexpectedly hosted just six days after the original schedule. The Current’s 2-1 victory stemmed from a rugged game plan that would have suited any venue but felt particularly apt amid Icahn’s elements. The teams contended with swirling winds during New York’s first truly cold weekend of the season, while Gotham battled a setting sun that impaired visibility in the first half. Bethune’s strike stood as the lone on-field spectacle on Randall’s Island.
“We knew it was going to be a physical game, without a doubt,” Current forward Haley Hopkins said. “Like I’ve said a million times, Gotham’s a very, very good team and so we had to be super disciplined in our structure and catch them on their transition and we were just able to put the ball in the back of the net when we had our opportunities.”
The introduction of Gotham’s Rose Lavelle, who had been managing minor fitness concerns in recent weeks, did little to alter the match’s chaotic rhythm. Much like their quarterfinal win over the Seattle Reign a week prior, Gotham’s attack lacked incision despite its star power. Across 180 minutes of possession-dominant play, the NWSL Shield winners registered zero shots on target and a mere 0.66 expected goals; midseason marquee signing Sam Kerr failed to attempt a single shot across the tie and has managed just one attempt in her last five appearances. To call them unlucky would be generous; their bright start to the second half only lent a surreal quality to their inability to test the goalkeeper.
“I think we were kind of our own worst enemy today,” midfielder Savannah McCaskill said. “I think at times we played into what they wanted to do and their style of play. They want a very chippy game. They want to get into tackles. They want to draw fouls. They want to break up the game. They want to play long and that’s not our style. We want to keep the ball. We want to control tempo, and we like to play pretty football. That’s what we pride ourselves on … but I think we need to find a better way to balance that out, especially in this league. How can we meet the demand of a chippy game while also controlling the tempo? I think we did a really good job when we played them at home the last time [a 2-1 win on Aug. 14]. They scored early but then we completely dominated the rest of the game and I think we failed to do that today and so I think that’s really the determining factor.”
In essence, the stage was set for Gotham to level through an own goal from Laney Rouse — a week after benefiting from another own goal by the Reign’s Jordyn Bugg. Those two own goals would comprise the entirety of Gotham’s postseason scoring, a meager return for the Shield winners and reigning champions who entered the playoffs as title favorites.
Gotham goalkeeper Ann-Katrin Berger then produced two crucial saves while defender Tierna Davidson marshaled a desperate rearguard, crafting a villain arc rivaled only by Argentina’s run to the World Cup final. Though the hosts had scrambled into parity by the 88th minute, the encroaching darkness and biting cold at a downsized stadium in an overlooked corner of New York seemed to demand extra time. One final smash-and-grab moment felt inevitable, though its origin remained uncertain — the Current had done the work to win, yet soccer’s inherent chaos had already infiltrated the contest.
Ultimately, it was the Current’s Haley Hopkins who authored the decisive moment in the 89th minute off — what else — a set piece, a free kick that allowed the forward to finally beat Berger with a shot off the crossbar. Having lost two of three meetings with Gotham this season, the Current secured their place in next week’s NWSL Championship (Saturday, 8 p.m. ET, CBS, Paramount+) on the back of a meticulously executed game plan.
“As much as we tried to analyze certain teams in the league that have given them trouble, we really took information from the games we’ve played against them, all the ways they challenged us,” Current head coach Chris Armas said. “There’s been games even where they get high [expected goals], too much progression, too much in our box and we just tried to then look at all the scenes and moments when we made it hard for them so we just tried to take from yesterday and apply it to today, [that] type of thing. We gave up zero shots on goal in 90 minutes. The commitment from our players to just will themselves to it to stick to a match plan that was going to be largely about taking away spaces, controlling the middle of the pitch and if we can do that on the day – and and we did that by running after them, too, and pressing in moments of high intensity – we not only might stop what they’re trying to do on one end and maybe force the turnovers that could challenge them so a little bit of a chess match there in moments.”
The Current were no underdogs, finishing fourth in the regular season and now riding a seven-game winning streak into the championship. Bethune’s brilliance illuminated Sunday, while the partnership of two-time NWSL MVP Temwa Chawinga and U.S. women’s national team standout Michelle Cooper adds formidable depth. Yet the achievement remains significant: they toppled a giant, eliminating the Shield winners and a side that has claimed five major trophies in four seasons.
“Gotham has just raised the bar around the league and in our country here, so the way they play, the way the coach sets them up, the talent on the team, the type of games they can put you in, you have to come with a plan,” Armas said. “They’re a team that, again, if iron sharpens iron type of thing, we try to push teams and we try to raise the bar.”
Gotham, however, did not resemble the league’s gold standard. Their dramatic reign, currently spearheaded by USWNT stars Lavelle and Jaedyn Shaw, rests on a staunch defensive structure that has masked an inconsistent offense. Lavelle and, particularly, Shaw have shouldered the creative burden en route to the Shield, while Kerr was expected to elevate the attack following Esther Gonzalez’s surprise departure for Saudi club Al Qadsiah. Gotham finished the regular season sixth in expected goals (49.01) but converted just 39 times, ranking in the league’s bottom six for goals scored. Head coach Juan Carlos Amoros is not sounding alarms yet, but as another offseason looms, the team’s attacking composition warrants scrutiny.
“Of course, we want to create more chances, more shots,” Amoros said. “We all do but we look at the way we play. We look at the way we create chances. We look at who does that. I think when it comes to these games, could we have [made] some better decisions? Yes, we did. We actually create some good moments. Yes, I wouldn’t over-think about it. Something that I’m happy [about]? No but at the same time, we work a lot to make sure that those moments happen. So you know the set pieces, those situations, the open plays, final decisions … Definitely, something that we want to be better [at]. We want to score more goals. I think that we are the best team defending in the league with our aggressive approach to defending but we want to also be able to create and score more goals.”
Gotham’s stadium logistics remain a persistent issue
More critically, Gotham were not afforded the treatment befitting a team that has elevated the league’s standard. Icahn Stadium possesses a certain charm and merits inclusion on the list of wonderfully eccentric venues that define American soccer — a delightfully chaotic slice of the world’s game. Yet it served as a backup for a club that has called Sports Illustrated Stadium home for five years, settling comfortably into a state-of-the-art, soccer-specific facility built for MLS’s Red Bull New York that holds 20,000 more spectators than Icahn’s 5,000-seat capacity. The pitch at Sports Illustrated Stadium, maintained by RBNY, had deteriorated, and with the primary tenants’ end-of-season friendly scheduled for the night before, there was insufficient time to remediate it. Icahn’s idiosyncrasies only underscored that Gotham — and the NWSL — should not have been there, even if Randall’s Island’s surface proved superior for the occasion.
“I want to be really clear and direct in saying that in these types of situations, the field is never an excuse,” winger Midge Purce said. “We lost today because we weren’t the better team. That being said, I would say it’s inexcusable. It’s not what you want in a professional league. It’s not what you want for women who are progressing in the United States and supposed to be one of the best leagues in the entire world. I think it’s a bad look for everyone involved and we always want to be at Sports Illustrated [Stadium] in front of our fans when we earned that right throughout the season but I would say it had no effect on performance today.”
The Current’s journey to Icahn Stadium does not conclude the NWSL’s improvisational efforts. Saturday’s semifinal, in which the Washington Spirit defeated the Utah Royals to secure a championship berth at their home venue of Audi Field, compounded the issue. One of the Spirit’s sponsors subsidized the cost to shift the Secretaries’ Cup — a Division III football game — by a few hours, yet both matches unfolded on a field marked with both soccer and football lines. Those gridiron lines will likely remain faintly visible for next week’s NWSL Championship, while the playing surface itself will face scrutiny in the buildup.
“I think we will never know what happened if we would have played [at Sports Illustrated Stadium] on a good pitch,” Amoros said. “I think it was the right decision to come here. I think the pitch in the other stadium was unfortunately unplayable under our view. The last couple of games we picked up injuries. Luckily, nothing that has been a season-ending injury but we have to protect our players and guarantee the quality of football so to thank the club, obviously.
“Overall, I think it’s been a sad weekend. I think also the situation in Washington yesterday. This league deserves better. The two, arguably, best teams, [most] consistent, having to deal with these situations and then yesterday, you sit down to watch that game around the world and you’re seeing those American football lines across today. Credit to the club and the fans. I think they’ve done an amazing job here. The fans welcomed us. The club has really shifted everything to play here but we couldn’t play in our ground where we could have had more people, where we are unbeaten in 13 games at the moment and but I think we took that decision, putting players’ safety first, and the outcome is the outcome.”
Also Read
- Jason Garrett: Steelers Lacked Fight in Bengals Defeat
- Tulsa’s Explosive Offense Outguns Florida Atlantic 38-21, clinching First Bowl Berth Since 2021
- Shoaib Akhtar Commends India U19’s Fierce Finish, Insists Pakistan Were Superior in Asia Cup
- Wales aims to regroup after recent setbacks with a morale boost from Tandy and a mindset transformation. [/TITLE> Following Wales’ defeat to England, the side keeps fifth place in the Northern Hemisphere league table after beating Scotland 15‑12 on Sunday. Wales still trails points difference behind Gregor Townsend’s team, as Scotland finishes its tour of Japan. Under Tandy’s guidance, squads have recorded three out of five victories in the Nations Championship against Fiji, Japan and New Zealand, while suffering early defeats in the summer round involving Argentina and South Africa. Captain Dewi Lake credited his players’ enhanced skills and construction of a stronger unit to Steve’s coaching staff, noted that “the belief and mindset have shifted dramatically,” and argued that these changes will enable Wales to defeat New Zealand and propel the team into ninth place worldwide.
