SAN MARCOS — A hush fell over the home stands at Rattler Stadium as the ball settled securely into the hands of Austin Lake Travis senior receiver Westin Smith.
Moments earlier, those same bleachers had trembled under the stomping cheers of Steele fans, whose team appeared headed for next week’s regional finals.
But Lake Travis sent the Knights home, handing Steele a 39-38 overtime defeat in a Class 6A Division I area-round playoff game Friday night after converting a two-point attempt.
The heartbreaking loss continues a pattern of narrow defeats for Steele against Lake Travis, with the Cavaliers prevailing in nearly every close meeting.
“We knew it would be a four-quarter game,” Steele coach David Saenz said. “I just wish it had ended differently.”
Steele took the first overtime possession after Lake Travis won the coin toss and chose to defend. Senior running back Marshall Kenner punched in his fifth touchdown of the night on a 6-yard run, and junior kicker Ralph Lara’s extra point was good. Lake Travis answered on its possession as senior running back Teddy Lofgren took a pitch and threw a 13-yard touchdown pass to senior receiver Luca Antoun at the front-right pylon on a trick play.
Lake Travis Cavaliers linebacker Owen Aird (9) celebrates an interception with his teammates in the first quarter of the area-round playoff game between the Lake Travis Cavaliers and Cibolo Steele Knights at Rattler Stadium in San Marcos, Nov. 20, 2026. (Sara Diggins/Austin American-Statesman)
Rather than heading to the sideline, Lake Travis junior quarterback Jason Carter stayed on the field to attempt the game-winning two-point conversion. His pass sailed over a leaping linebacker and into Smith’s arms.
“I’m proud of our seniors and how they competed all season,” Saenz said. “It came down to the final play, and that last two-point conversion didn’t go our way.”
Steele entered halftime with a 14-point lead, but Lake Travis chipped away at the deficit, tying the game with 8:41 remaining in regulation on a 37-yard field goal by Harrison Walters.
“Offensively, they converted some key third downs, extended drives, and got back into the game,” Saenz said of Lake Travis, which was scoreless in the second quarter.
Lake Travis recovered a possession in the third quarter with a successful onside kick, and Steele could not put the game away in the second half. The Knights’ final three drives produced a field goal and two punts.
Steele had dominated the early going despite a shaky start. Lake Travis scored first after intercepting a Steele pass, and Lofgren rushed for a 3-yard touchdown after linebacker Owen Aird picked off Knights quarterback DJ Green.
Steele responded immediately with a six-play scoring drive capped by Kenner’s 31-yard touchdown run. Kenner kept rolling in the second quarter, scoring all four of Steele’s first-half touchdowns. He finished his final high school game with nearly 300 rushing yards.
“He’s the heartbeat of our program and our team,” Saenz said of Kenner. “We’ll miss him, but he has bigger things ahead at the college level. He’s been an enormous part of our program.”
Steele concludes its season at 9-2-1. Lake Travis advances to face Brennan next week in the regional semifinals.
“They got hit early, but they responded and kept playing,” Saenz said of his team. “That’s what makes me most proud—the way they competed from start to finish.”
Cibolo Steele Knights wide receiver Jayden Casiano (18) narrowly misses scoring a touchdown as Lake Travis Cavaliers defensive back Carter Lofton (8) makes a tackle in the second quarter of the area-round playoff game between the Lake Travis Cavaliers and Cibolo Steele Knights at Rattler Stadium in San Marcos, Nov. 20, 2026. (Sara Diggins/Austin American-Statesman)