James Mercante, head of admiralty litigation at Gallo Vitucci Klar, outlines the upcoming legal proceedings following the collision between the Atlantic Asphalt tanker and the docked American Heritage cruise ship in New Orleans.
The accident, which took place on Friday at the Port of New Orleans, involved an asphalt tanker that lost steering control and struck the moored American Heritage cruise ship, causing it to capsize alongside the pier. All passengers and crew were rescued, but the incident is expected to ignite a major legal dispute over liability.
According to the National Transportation Safety Board, the Atlantic Asphalt—a tanker specialized in transporting asphalt and bitumen—collided with the stationary American Heritage cruise liner after losing steering control. In maritime terminology, this type of incident is called an allision, where a moving vessel strikes a fixed object.
The Atlantic Asphalt is owned by Nave Shipping, a Liberia‑registered company, and is operated by Thome Ship Management, based in Singapore. Nave is a subsidiary of the state‑owned China State Shipbuilding Corporation, according to the Associated Press and shipping tracker MarineTraffic.
In an interview with FOX Business, James Mercante, head of admiralty litigation at Gallo Vitucci Klar, noted that “the ownership structure in shipping is very difficult sometimes,” explaining that “owners often protect themselves by layering multiple companies.”
AT LEAST 100 PEOPLE PULLED FROM MISSISSIPPI RIVER AFTER NEW ORLEANS SHIP CRASH AS LENGTHY SALVAGE EFFORT LOOMS
A tugboat stabilizes the riverboat American Heritage after it capsized following a collision with the tanker Atlantic Asphalt on the Mississippi River near the Port of New Orleans on Nov. 13, 2026. (Michael DeMocker/Getty Images)
Mercante emphasized that the vessel’s flag state—whether Chinese, Liberian, or Singaporean—would be irrelevant. “What matters is the insurance company behind the operation,” he said.
He added, “This is a well‑known asphalt tanker operating in U.S. waters with proper insurance, and that is what claimants ultimately care about.”
On Friday, the Port of New Orleans petitioned for the arrest of the Atlantic Asphalt, a maritime procedure that places a lien on the vessel and allows it to be detained until financial security is posted for the damages. A federal court in Louisiana granted the request within hours.
NEW ORLEANS PORT SEEKS TANKER SEIZURE AFTER CRUISE SHIP CRASH SPARKS $1M LAWSUIT
The tanker Atlantic Asphalt shows signs of damage after it collided with the riverboat American Heritage. (Michael DeMocker/Getty Images)
When claimants seek security—either a letter of undertaking from the insurer or a bond—the identity of the insurance company will become clear, as that carrier will post the security to release the vessel from arrest,” Mercante said.
He noted, “Ships don’t earn revenue while idle; they could lose hundreds of thousands of dollars daily. After the NTSB and Coast Guard complete their investigations, the vessel must be released to resume operations.”
The release will follow once the insurer posts the required security, after which the vessel will be freed and the litigation can proceed.
NEW ORLEANS CRUISE SHIP DISASTER TIMELINE REVEALS TANKER’S TROUBLED PAST AND FRANTIC FINAL MINUTES
All aboard the American Heritage were rescued after the incident with no fatalities. A total of 32 people were taken to hospitals for injuries. (Michael DeMocker/Getty Images)
Mercante anticipates multiple claims, including a total loss of the American Heritage’s hull, personal injury damages, business interruption at the Port of New Orleans, and extensive salvage costs for the sunken cruise ship.
He explained, “The cruise ship remains capsized in the Mississippi River, and the port is already seeking bids from marine salvors to recover it—either by righting and towing the vessel or demolishing it in situ.”
He added, “The salvage operation will likely cost tens of millions of dollars, and this claim will be pursued against the Atlantic Asphalt as well.”
Mercante concluded, “The vessel will face extensive litigation covering personal injuries, damage to the Port of New Orleans, business interruption, hull loss, and injury claims. The case promises to be a complex and closely watched legal battle.”

