The Toronto Maple Leafs have stumbled out of the gate in disappointing fashion, enduring one of the franchise’s most forgettable homestands in recent memory. With injuries mounting and losses accumulating, the club finds itself searching for answers.
While inconsistent performances from core players and roster depth concerns have contributed to the slide, several questionable decisions behind the bench by head coach Jim Hiller have exacerbated the situation.
McKenna Removed From Top Power-Play Unit
Perhaps the most perplexing move has been the decision to remove rookie Gavin McKenna from the first power-play unit following John Tavares’ return from injury. While Tavares has established a strong track record as a net-front presence with the man advantage, the power play was operating efficiently with McKenna in the lineup and has since gone cold.

As of November 15, the Maple Leafs have converted just once in ten opportunities with the man advantage since McKenna’s demotion—a unit that began the season as one of the team’s most reliable weapons. While Toronto has also seen fewer power-play chances overall, the opportunities they have generated have failed to produce offense, a critical shortcoming during the current downturn.
Hiller could reintegrate McKenna at any point, but his deployment of the teenager to date suggests such a move is unlikely.
The Goaltending Carousel
Preseason expectations pointed to a timeshare between Anthony Stolarz and Sergei Bobrovsky. Twenty-plus games in, with the team struggling to support Bobrovsky and the veteran netminder unable to steady the ship, the continued reliance on him is surprising.
Bobrovsky carries a $7 million cap hit and a Vezina Trophy pedigree, but his performance this season has not reflected comfort in the Maple Leafs’ crease—and it is costing the club valuable standings points.
Through 13 appearances, Bobrovsky owns a 3-8-2 record with a 3.47 goals-against average and an .881 save percentage. By comparison, Stolarz is 5-4-0 in nine starts with a 2.69 GAA and .906 SV%. While Bobrovsky may yet reclaim the starter’s mantle before season’s end, he is not playing like a number-one goaltender at present.
With the season slipping away, Hiller must end the rotation and ride the hot hand in Stolarz.
McKenna Relegated to a Depth Role
The final concern circles back to McKenna and his limited overall usage—not solely on the power play. Early in the campaign, the Maple Leafs’ first-overall selection was benched for the majority of the second period and the entire third period of a game in which the team was on the brink of defeat.
Hiller attributed the decision to an oversight caused by a flurry of penalties, explaining he could not find an appropriate moment to return the young star to the ice. Now, amid a six-game losing streak, the coach has yet to explore moving McKenna up the lineup.
Line combinations at Monday’s practice, ahead of a matchup with the Chicago Blackhawks, remained unchanged from the 1-0 loss to the Edmonton Oilers. McKenna remained on the third line, while Ryan Tverberg retained a second-line role alongside Tavares and William Nylander.
One could frame this as a learning curve for McKenna. However, given his production when afforded opportunity, Hiller must reconsider where his top prospect slots into the lineup—if for no other reason than to spark a turnaround and salvage a season that held significant promise before a series of questionable coaching decisions clouded the outlook.