It’s bracket time, as the MLS Cup playoffs are finally here. The Wild Card round kicks off on Thursday night, with 18 teams — still too many, arguably — entering the gauntlet that defines the postseason. All eyes will be on Nashville SC, who earned a first-round bye by winning the Supporters’ Shield and setting a new MLS regular-season points record with 77. History tells us, though, that any side can fall in a single match, because succeeding over 34 games is a very different proposition than surviving October and November.
The Wild Card round is a one-off, win-or-go-home affair, while the first round shifts to a best-of-three series, with matches decided by a penalty shootout if tied. That changes the calculus somewhat, particularly for a team that grabs an early goal in the opening game, since two further chances to advance remain. But where there are playoffs, there must be predictions, so let’s get to it.
Wild Card round
- Participants: Seattle Sounders, Real Salt Lake, Orlando City SC, FC Cincinnati
- Advance: Real Salt Lake, Orlando City SC
The Seattle Sounders arrive in a difficult position. They have built a reputation as a side that can never be counted out of MLS Cup contention, but they begin the postseason without one of their best defenders. Center back Jackson Ragen was suspended for two games following a disciplinary review of his challenge on Los Angeles FC’s Jacob Shaffelburg. Seattle have returned to full health otherwise, yet the absence opens the door for Real Salt Lake to escape the Wild Card round.
In Orlando, this is one of the marquee matchups of the entire postseason, as Evander and Antoine Griezmann go head to head in a game where defense is optional. Both clubs entered the season with loftier ambitions, so defeat carries serious implications. But having won Newcomer of the Year, Griezmann — supported by Orlando’s potent attack — should prove too much for Cincinnati, sending the Lions into the first round of the playoffs proper.
First round
- Participants: Vancouver Whitecaps, Real Salt Lake, San Jose Earthquakes, Houston Dynamo, St. Louis City SC, Los Angeles FC, FC Dallas, Portland Timbers, Nashville SC, Orlando City SC, Chicago Fire, Charlotte FC, New England Revolution, Philadelphia Union, Inter Miami, Columbus Crew
- Advance: Vancouver Whitecaps, San Jose Earthquakes, St. Louis City SC, FC Dallas, Nashville SC, Charlotte FC, New England Revolution, Inter Miami
The parity in MLS this season, especially in the Western Conference, is genuine. Tell me anyone could come out of the West and I’d believe it. Vancouver may be the team to beat, but losing Sebastian Berhalter and Andres Cubas midseason hurt the squad. Jesper Sorensen has done plenty to keep the Whitecaps afloat, though they remain vulnerable — more of a concern in the later rounds, depending on how the bracket settles. St. Louis City SC have already exceeded expectations by winning the U.S. Open Cup, and if Alexandru Matan is on his game they may be unbeatable, but they can run hot and cold. Add in Bruce Arena still settling into the league and the cardiac kids of Dallas — not to mention the brilliance of Petar Musa — and that gives us the advancing sides. I would apologize to Los Angeles FC, but since Steve Cherundolo’s departure this is a side that has faltered, and it deserves a long, hard look once the season ends.
In the East, we’re living in B.J. Callaghan’s world. Los Angeles FC remain the last team to pull off the double of the Supporters’ Shield and MLS Cup, and it’s a difficult feat for Nashville to match — but this team has conceded just 25 goals across a full season. They can score, they can grind a game to a halt, and they have any number of ways to make life miserable for an opponent. In a best-of-three, good luck getting past them. Speaking of slowing things down, the New England Revolution are a worst-case matchup for the battling Cavan Sullivans of Philadelphia. Joshua Wynder has steadied the defense in front of Matt Turner, and while the Revolution may lack a high ceiling as currently constructed, the floor is remarkably high in this unusual setup. Charlotte against Chicago is effectively a coin flip. Then there’s Miami versus Columbus. Like the Union, the Crew can win because their attacking upside is so high, and Miami are a flawed team — but Lionel Messi is still doing Lionel Messi things. As long as that remains true, I’m rarely betting against the Herons.
Conference semifinals
- Participants: Vancouver Whitecaps, San Jose Earthquakes, St. Louis City SC, FC Dallas, Nashville SC, Charlotte FC, New England Revolution, Inter Miami
- Advance: Vancouver Whitecaps, St. Louis City SC, Nashville SC, Inter Miami
Now the playoffs truly begin. These are single-elimination games, with the best of the best meeting head on. San Jose’s run ends here, while St. Louis and Dallas meet in an evenly matched clash to decide the other Western semifinalist. Nashville’s defense delivers another suffocating performance to get past Charlotte, and Messi drives Inter Miami beyond the Revolution, setting up a fascinating pair of conference finals.
Conference finals
- Participants: Vancouver Whitecaps, St. Louis City SC, Nashville SC, Inter Miami
- Advance: Vancouver Whitecaps, Inter Miami
Okay, I swear this wasn’t supposed to go chalk, with three of the top four regular-season finishers reaching the conference finals — but arriving at the end of the season and concluding that the good teams really are good shouldn’t be revolutionary. Thomas Muller and Brian White are more than enough to push the Whitecaps into the MLS Cup final, where the Eastern Conference once again comes down to Messi versus Hany Mukhtar. Nashville may be the better-coached side, but Miami have found a way with their backs against the wall, producing a rematch of last season’s MLS Cup final.
MLS Cup
Participants: Vancouver Whitecaps, Inter Miami
Winners: Inter Miami
There it is: Messi and Muller, like a top-tier Champions League matchup. It has been a playoff gauntlet, but the more things change, the more they stay the same. Muller and Messi have met 11 times, with Muller claiming seven wins to Messi’s four. After getting the better of Muller last season, though, Messi won’t surrender a chance at a second consecutive MLS Cup — even if this one takes place in Vancouver, amid the uncertain future of BC Place as the Whitecaps’ home.
Also Read
- NHL Thursday Night: 12-Game Slate Features Playoff Rematches and Stanley Cup Preview
- Cameron Bancroft Shares Kurta-and-Tilak Birthday Ritual as Sandpapergate Debate Reignites
- Texans Debut Rivalry Threads, Commanders Unveil ‘Hail Raiser’ Black Uniforms for Week 11
- Nick Khan Addresses TKO Leadership Dynamics Following WWE-UFC Merger

