Hilary Cass, a paediatrician and House of Lords member who led a major review of children’s gender services, has stated she can no longer support proposed legislation banning conversion practices related to sexual orientation and transgender identity.

Initially supportive of the bill announced last summer, Cass now argues the proposed ban is creating a chilling effect among healthcare professionals and could endanger parental rights.

The legislation, introduced in June and currently under parliamentary review, aims to prohibit abusive practices seeking to change an individual’s sexual orientation or gender identity in England and Wales, with violations carrying unlimited fines and up to five years’ imprisonment.

The bill has drawn criticism from religious leaders and the former chief of Britain’s rights watchdog, who argue the legislation is unnecessary since harmful practices are already covered by existing law, and warn it could undermine parental and religious freedoms.

Appearing before a joint committee of MPs and peers this week, Cass warned the draft ban is already impacting healthcare professionals, who fear professional repercussions even when providing appropriate and ethical care.

“The draft bill is already having a chilling effect on healthcare professionals who fear they may be accused of falling far below professional standards, even when they have conducted appropriate and ethical therapy,” she said.

“Standards are hotly disputed in this contentious area and no professional wants to risk complaints and even prosecution, even if they are later exonerated. It is the process which ends up being an unwarranted punishment,” she added.

A government spokesperson told the BBC they are taking all evidence from the committee seriously, stating they “want to get this ban right.”

Last week, psychologist Dr Igi Moon, representing a coalition of over 25 health, counselling and psychotherapy organisations signed onto a memorandum of understanding to end conversion practices, voiced support for the bill.

“The draft bill is something that all the organisations on the MOU support,” they said. “We want a legal ban.”

Cass’s 2024 review of NHS gender care for under-18s found children had been let down by insufficient research and evidence surrounding medical interventions, prompting sweeping changes including a ban on puberty blockers.

“I was pleased to see that the government is bringing forward legislation which not only gives a clearer definition of what conversion practices are, compared with previous drafts, but also what they are not,” she commented.

She had previously emphasized the importance of healthcare professionals being “able to do their job without fear of litigation,” but now confirms she cannot support the bill without radical changes she doubts are feasible.

“I can’t support this bill as it has too many problems, including the risk to parents,” she said. “It would have to be radically changed to be workable and I am not sure that is possible.”

Upon the draft legislation’s summer publication, former equalities under-secretary Olivia Bailey vowed it would “prevent and protect” LGBTQ+ people from abusive attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity.

The government maintains a “high threshold for criminality,” with the bill targeting only acts deemed abusive, intended to change identity, and causing “real harm” to the individual.

Source link

Exit mobile version