A long-awaited review of the personal independence payment (Pip) is expected to recommend a sweeping overhaul of the benefit this week, arriving just days after a separate report urged that it be scrapped in part.
The final report from the committee co-chaired by social security minister Stephen Timms could be published as early as Tuesday, handing the prime minister, Andy Burnham, one of his most politically delicate decisions to date.
Drawing on input from disability rights advocates, the review is understood to closely mirror a draft set of recommendations released in September. Those proposals called for a range of reforms, most notably to how claimants are assessed, so that conditions which fluctuate over time are better reflected.
The changes would reshape Pip, a benefit designed to help disabled people cover the additional costs of disability. An interim report from Timms’s committee described the payment as widely valued but “no longer fit for purpose”.
Under the review’s proposals, the benefit would be retained across all age groups. That contrasts with a report published last week by Alan Milburn on youth worklessness, which recommended abolishing Pip entirely for adults under 25 and replacing it with an “additional cost allowance” as part of a broader package of employment support for younger people.
Government officials have sought to downplay suggestions of a conflict, noting that Milburn’s review was commissioned after Timms’s process was already under way, and that roughly 90% of the Pip caseload involves claimants over the age of 25.
With Timms’s recommendations understood to be wide-ranging, however, Burnham and his ministers will face a series of decisions on how to proceed on a highly sensitive issue. Keir Starmer was compelled to shelve planned reforms in 2025 following a substantial rebellion by Labour MPs.
Milburn’s proposals to scrap Pip and universal credit health payments for under-25s, part of an effort to improve jobs and training for young people not in education, employment or training, prompted alarm among disability campaigners and charities.
The review’s steering group is co-chaired by Timms alongside disability rights advocates Clenton Farquharson and Sharon Brennan, with most of its 12 members drawing on lived experience of disability or long-term health conditions.
Some members of the Timms review board are said to be uneasy about the scale of Milburn’s plans for Pip, which would remove £3.6bn in spending directed at young people. “Some members are really concerned,” one source told the Guardian.
The report is expected to set out both short-term overhauls, deliverable within the current spending round, and longer-term reforms. Much of the detail on the latter would fall to ministers to determine before they legislate next year.
Burnham is under pressure from the Conservatives to bring down the overall cost of working-age benefits. He has said this is his intention, while resisting what he described as “crude cuts”, arguing that such measures often simply shift costs elsewhere.
Framed by ministers as a pioneering “co-produced” policy effort, the Timms review was viewed as an attempt to rebuild trust among disabled people after the collapse of the previous Pip plans under Starmer, which had centred on £5bn in savings.
An interim report in July, followed by further findings in September, established a shared view that Pip was unfit for purpose and required major reform to become fair, humane and efficient. It raised the possibility that some claimants might in future receive “in kind” support such as services, aids or training alongside basic cash payments.
Even so, it stressed that cash payments were “the foundation” of any reformed disability benefit, that the payment would remain non-means tested, and that any “reformed benefit will be designed with disabled people and those with long-term health conditions, and tested to make sure it works before it is rolled out”. It made no reference to abolishing Pip for under-25s or any other age group.
Until recently, most disability charities had remained hopeful that the Timms review, whose remit excluded Pip’s costs or potential spending cuts, would deliver the reforms needed to improve the lives of the 4 million adults who claim it.
But the timing and breadth of the Milburn review, which ministers have conspicuously welcomed, have shaken that confidence.
Also Read
- Asia Cup Rising Stars: India-Pakistan Rivalry Fills Qatar With World Cup Intensity
- Israel’s Climb to the World’s 25th-Largest Economy Holds Lessons for Europe
- Saudi Foreign Minister Prince Faisal bin Farhan Holds Regional Talks with Pakistan’s Ishaq Dar
- Kerch Bridge Collapse Signals Intensifying Ukraine Conflict Timeline


