A new analysis of fossil fuel trade dating back to 1850 identifies Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia as the three largest exporters of carbon dioxide in history.

Russia leads the ranking, drawing on its enormous coal, oil and gas reserves. When the emissions generated by burning those exported fuels are counted, the country accounts for more than 70 gigatonnes of CO2 through the end of 2025.

Saudi Arabia, one of the world’s leading oil and gas producers, follows with roughly 60 gigatonnes of exported CO2. The kingdom has long been a resistant voice at the annual UN climate negotiations.

Australia ranks third, well behind the top two, with more than 25 gigatonnes of exported CO2, only slightly ahead of Venezuela. The findings surface as Australia presides over this year’s UN climate summit, Cop31, now in its second week in Turkey. The country has yet to set a deadline for the use or export of fossil fuels, which account for roughly two-fifths of its export economy.

chart showing top 1o exporters of fossil fuel emissions 1850-2025, with Russia and Saudi Arabia the greatest

Louise Hutchins, convener of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, said the report exposes deep flaws in climate diplomacy. “This analysis tells you a lot about what’s going wrong with climate negotiations. Here at Cop31, governments claim there’s not enough money to tackle the climate crisis, while Australia, Russia and Saudi Arabia, that have amassed fortunes from fossil fuels, continue to wield pivotal political power in this consensus-based process.”

“Just look at Australia. Its contribution to global heating more than doubles when fossil fuel exports are counted. Yet it is co-presiding over the very negotiations where climate finance talks are once again in stalemate.”

“Responsibility is on the wealthy, the powerful and the profiteers. Those who made fortunes from fossil fuels must pay for the damage.”

The study, carried out by Carbon Brief and reviewed by the Guardian, attributes responsibility for CO2 emissions to the country that extracts the fossil fuels, in contrast to most analyses, which focus on the countries where the emissions are ultimately released.

Measuring emissions by their point of origin reframes both the global economy and historical accountability. Exporting nations can rank comparatively low among greenhouse gas emitters, since those figures are based on domestic fossil fuel consumption.

The analysis also finds that the US and China, the world’s two largest current emitters, still carry greater responsibility for historical emissions than Russia, Saudi Arabia or Australia. In addition to importing vast amounts of fossil fuels, both have burned substantial volumes of their own supplies.

chart showing historical emissions with the US and China the greatest

The Cop28 outcome agreed in Dubai in 2023 urged every country to help drive a global shift away from fossil fuels, yet it established no timetable or action plan to achieve it. On Monday afternoon at Cop31, Australia released a first draft of a possible summit outcome that included a call for “the immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.”

Many countries, however, including Saudi Arabia, have taken firmer negotiating stances since Dubai, and the absence of the US under Donald Trump has eased the pressure on them to seek compromise. Observers widely expect the “immediate transition away” language to be diluted across the several further rounds of cover decision drafts that are likely to follow.

Saudi Arabia, Russia and their allies in the Arab Group, among others, are even resisting the notion of issuing a cover text altogether, a stance that could stall talks further.

The thinktank Climate Analytics published separate research on Tuesday indicating that Australia, despite chairing Cop31, appears to have no intention of scaling back its own fossil fuel extraction.

Coal mines are still being approved that would keep operating until 2088, decades after all nations are meant to have reached net zero greenhouse gas emissions around mid-century.

“It’s abundantly clear Australia is not ‘doing its part’ as the prime minister claimed here in Turkey last week,” said Climate Analytics CEO Bill Hare. “There is a deep contradiction in a government position that champions climate ambition abroad but plans for continued fossil fuel exports, with approvals for coalmines and gasfields that lock in production for decades.”

Reconciling these contradictions is politically fraught for the Australian government. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese attended Cop31 last week, but at home he faces mounting pressure from a resurgent One Nation party, which is polling strongly and rejects both net zero and climate science.

Australia, Saudi Arabia and Russia were each approached for comment.

Asad Rehman, chief executive of Friends of the Earth, said: “It’s time for the deadly tango between the producers of fossil fuels, and those locked into dependency on oil and gas, to have its last dance. We must turn off the tap on fossil fuels and push richer nations to commit to a fair, fast and fully funded phaseout. That means real public finance, and access to the technology that can make it possible, for the countries bearing the brunt of climate breakdown.”

Source link

Exit mobile version