Why do Liverpool’s big-money transfers keep failing to deliver?

Multiple Authors

Bradley Barcola extended his arms despairingly; Ryan Gravenberch turned on his heel and sighed; Milos Kerkez punched the air in frustration.

All of the above came after Florian Wirtz had fired wildly off target in Liverpool’s 3-0 defeat to Manchester City on Sunday, with each of his teammates’ reactions shown in a clip that has been viewed millions of times on social media. It was a fairly innocuous sequence — the kind that occurs in almost every match at the elite level — but, in this instance, it was held up as a microcosm of Wirtz’s enduring struggles at Anfield.

The 23-year-old was once again ineffective against City, and was taken out of the match after Gravenberch’s red card midway through the second half. The fact that Wirtz was coach Andoni Iraola’s first choice to be withdrawn while his team were a goal down and in desperate need of inspiration was damning, considering he was recruited to be Liverpool’s main creative spark when he joined the club from Bayer Leverkusen for an initial £100 million only 16 months ago.

Editor’s Choice

Two Related

“I think he needs to come out of the team,” former Liverpool defender Jamie Carragher said on Sky Sports after the match. “I said that last time out, and I’m going to say it again. I said Liverpool played well today for a lot of the game before the Gravenberch red card, but they didn’t create a chance … and that’s what you bought Wirtz for. He’s not giving you anything defensively, and he’s not giving you anything going the other way.”

It was a scathing assessment, but one echoed across the board by fans and pundits alike. Yet some maintain that Wirtz’s chronic underperformance in the Premier League signals a broader issue at the Reds.

Over the past two summer windows, Liverpool’s net spend reached £480 million. Three of the players signed during that period — Wirtz, Barcola and Alexander Isak — arrived for fees of £100 million or more. However, all have drawn intense scrutiny at Anfield.

In the case of Barcola, patience is warranted, but the cohort of players signed in summer 2025 faces mounting pressure to deliver. After nearly a decade of surgical recruitment, Liverpool’s recent spending sprees feel more like a hindrance than a help.

Amid Rising Pressure on Liverpool’s Major-Scale Stars

Liverpool’s £450 million outlay in summer 2025 aimed to lay foundations for a dynasty shortly after their title win a few months earlier. Targeted were young talents who had already excelled at the top level yet retained growth potential within a renewed squad identity.

Hindsight offers clarity, but when Liverpool signed Florian Wirtz in June 2025 — having been Leverkusen’s standout during their 2023‑24 Bundesliga dominant season — there was little promise of success. Regarded as one of Europe’s finest young talents, Wirtz proceeded to deliver just seven goals and ten assists in fifty‑six appearances. His final prior goal for Liverpool came in a 3‑1 win over Crystal Palace in April, with merely two assists in eight outings this season.

ESPN — Your One Stack

Join host Dan Thomas, Craig Burley, Shaka Hislop, and colleagues for the latest highlights and debates on the biggest storylines. Stream on ESPN+ (U.S. only).
Sign Up Now

While rival clubs such as Manchester United and Chelsea drew fire for costly misfires, Liverpool’s recruitment apparatus long earned them the label of elite. Pioneered by sporting director Michael Edwards and research director Ian Graham, the department turned quality signees into club assets before committing substantial sums to a handful of transformative talents.

Since 2020, however, Liverpool’s market trend has shifted decisively toward inconsistency. Success arrives — Diogo Jota, Ibrahima Konée and Alexis Mac Allister among the highlights — but disappointment lurks too. While Darwin Núñez underdelivered after his £64 million move from Benfica in 2022, Thiago Alcantara was sidelined by injury concerns and Federico Chiesa has struggled to reclaim his pre‑Juventus form since arriving from Italy in 2024.

A rapidly-changing rear operation further intensifies the challenges. Liverpool have cycled through four sporting directors since 2022, with Julian Ward returning for a second stint after Richard Hughes departed last month.

Balancing finances has become harder as the Reds lose significant value from departing stars. They previously turned profits by recouping fees from long‑standing players, but now face difficulties as Konité and Salah left on free transfers, Real Madrid paid only £10 million for Trent Alexander‑Arnold, and key players like Curtis Jones moved abroad for modest sums while Harvey Elliott faced a setback at Valencia following a problematic loan.

Though external factors contributed to these exits, the cumulative loss of income underscores the difficulty of maintaining financial stability without retaining marquee talent.

Mountain‑Top Expectations for Anfield’s New Cast

Liverpool spent £450 million in the summer of 2025 to aid a dynasty push after clinching the title mere weeks earlier. Their targets were performers with proven pedigree yet untapped ceiling potential destined for progression within a revamped side.

When Wirtz was recruited, expectations were sky‑high given his status as one of Europe’s premier youth players. Reality, however, diverged sharply. Over fifty‑six games under the Liverpool shirt, the midfielder has netted only seven goals and provided ten assists.

His tally continued low recently: his most recent goal for the Reds arrived in a 3‑1 victory over Crystal Palace last month, with just two assists across eight appearances this season.

Watch ESPN FC Daily on ESPN+

Star guests Dan Thomas, Craig Burley, Shaka Hislop and others break down the latest moments, debating the principal storylines. Available on ESPN+ (U.S. only).

Even Rayan Cherki — who discussed opportunities at Manchester City before landing his move to PSG from Lyon — has logged tangible production despite earning a £34 million fee that fell far short of Wirtz’s premium.

Former Liverpool manager Jürgen Klopp defended the youngster after naming him to Germany’s national team last month. “Attacking players always benefit from a cohesive unit,” Klopp told reporters. “Anyone who loves football can still assess how outstanding Florian Wirtz is as a player.”

Critics argue that Klopp erred in supporting Wirtz’s recent Liverpool displays. That critique intensified after Barcelona’s 2‑0 win over Serbia, where Wirtz could not replicate his international brilliance. As the buzz grows louder, his form has seemingly evaporated; observers describe him as a player lacking confidence, one whose performance lacks the spark needed to sustain momentum until sudden improvement.

The path forward requires a measurable turnaround, because without a resurgence, rebuilding credibility becomes increasingly perilous.

Other Notable Signees Worth Watching

Beyond the headline pursuit, Liverpool secured two eager prospects in Víctor Muñoz and Jérémy Jacquet, while lending Barcelona captain Ronald Araújo for a brief stint that has proved productive, including a promising £47 million option for permanent acquisition.

Yet reliance on marquee names leaves gaps elsewhere. Susceptible defenses to the front line remain limited — despite transfers of Isak, Cody Gakpo and Dominik Szoboszlai — highlighting the strategic advantage of diversifying beyond the top‑tier imports.

With Iraola still charting the new phase of leadership, successful delivery from major acquisitions now stands as the decisive test. The club’s upward trajectory hinges on whether its financial ambition translates into on‑field excellence.