In 2024, the DESI collaboration released a startling report. When researchers merged their observations with existing data, the Lambda-CDM model failed to account for all the measurements. A better fit emerged from an exotic theory that replaced lambda—the constant vacuum energy—with a form of energy that weakens over time. A year later, an analysis of additional data reached the same conclusion.
Meanwhile, the DES collaboration continued examining the galaxies it had photographed. Those researchers compiled a different contribution to the dataset: a detailed record of the cosmic tug-of-war.
Gravity draws matter—primarily dark matter—together, while dark energy pushes it apart. By measuring how matter has clumped across different eras, cosmologists can infer how the strength of dark energy has changed over time.
There’s something that doesn’t fit. We’re trying to figure out what that something is.
Simone Ferraro, University of California, Berkeley
DES evaluates this clumping through three methods, explained Sujeong Lee, a physicist at Ohio University. First, DES measures how tightly visible galaxies cluster, revealing how much dark matter surrounds them. Second, it maps foreground visible matter by detecting how it distorts light from background galaxies. Third, it maps foreground dark matter using a similar approach.
Each method involves comparing hundreds of millions of galaxy pairs, searching for minute distortions in their positions and shapes. After seven years of analysis, the collaboration published its final results in early 2026. “It’s been a real tour de force,” said Ferraro, who is not part of DES. “It pushed the analysis to a new level.”
Alongside these measurements, DES reprocessed a catalog of 1,600 recently observed supernovae, producing the sharpest view yet of the modern universe. “I trust the DES-reanalyzed supernova data much more than I trust any other supernova dataset,” said Seshadri Nadathur, a DESI cosmologist.
Cosmologists have now assembled their most comprehensive file on the universe to date. DES combined its map of matter clumping, its supernova catalog, DESI’s galaxy-shell data, and a cosmic microwave background image, then tested how well Lambda-CDM could explain the full cosmic history.
The answer: not very well. In their final report, DES scientists found that their data fit somewhat better with the theory that dark energy is unstable and has weakened in recent eons. In statistical terms, DES reports a “three-sigma” preference for the new theory—enough to warrant attention, especially because it combines data gathered through different methods, though it remains well short of the “five-sigma” threshold physicists require to claim a discovery.

