French Ministers Rebuke Le Pen’s ‘Potemkin’ Budget Plan

By Romain Gutkind with AFP, AP

Published on 07/10/2026 – 7:55 GMT+2

Two senior French government officials have sharply condemned the alternative budget plan presented by Marine Le Pen, the head of the National Rally (RN) and the leading candidate in the 2027 presidential polls.

ADVERTISEMENT

ADVERTISEMENT

Critics: ‘You Are Dreaming in Colour’

Economy Minister Roland Lescure retorted, “You’re dreaming in colour,” while Public Accounts Minister David Amiel labeled the proposal a “Potemkin budget, made of cardboard.”

Projected Savings of 140 Billion Euros

Le Pen’s programme pledges 140 billion euros in savings by 2032. This would reduce the public deficit to below 3% by 2030, down from the roughly 5.4% projected for 2026, and lower France’s national debt to 112% of GDP from its current 119%, alongside 30 billion euros in tax cuts.

The RN bases these projected savings on immigration reforms, reduced contributions to the EU, and lower spending by local authorities.

Pension Reforms

Despite this, Le Pen proposes restoring the retirement age to 62, or potentially 60, from the current 64. She argues a return to 60 is feasible through “a major reform of individual and collective capital-funded schemes.”

Party Defends the Vision

“Yes, we do dream in colour; it is France’s rebirth with Marine Le Pen,” stated RN MP Jean-Philippe Tanguy.

Officials point out the RN’s plan relies on a growth forecast of 1.8%. “That is well above what all serious French and international economists are projecting,” fired back Lescure.

The ‘Golden Rule’

The RN seeks to enshrine a constitutional “golden rule” mandating that governments reduce public debt annually.

Lescure argued it is not enough “to write a text into the Constitution for the savings to follow.”

The minister highlighted the 9 billion euros in savings the RN claims from cutting France’s EU contribution. “That would need to be approved by our 26 partners,” he noted, adding “that is far from certain.” He warned that even if approved, those hit first would be “French farmers, the main beneficiaries of the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), French companies that receive subsidies, and French research laboratories funded by European research programmes.”

Moreover, Lescure characterized the 15 billion euros in immigration-related savings as “measures that are for the most part unconstitutional (…), slapdash measures cobbled together on the hoof.”

Environmental Policy Overhaul

Le Pen also aims to “end loss-making subsidies for intermittent energy sources” and promises “a major structural reform” of “environmental and energy policy,” with the ambition to reach “carbon neutrality before 2050.”

Characterized as ‘Potemkin’

For Public Accounts Minister David Amiel, the RN’s proposal remains “a Potemkin budget, all cardboard and paint.”

Source link