Campaigners have welcomed a recent call to review consent legislation, voiced by a survivor of drug‑facilitated rape, while emphasizing that broader concerns about sexual assault also demand attention.
Joanne Young, who was drugged, raped by her husband, and later sexually abused by men he invited into their home, warned that there are serious questions about how the law handles consent.
Philip Young, 50, posted an advertisement for his then‑wife, Joanne Young, on dating and swinging platforms, describing it as a shared “kink.” In reality, he had been sedating her, rendering her “inanimate,” enabling the men who responded to the adverts to commit sexual acts, the jury was told.
The former Conservative councillor pleaded guilty earlier this year to numerous abuse charges against his ex‑wife, who has waived her right to anonymity.
After four men were found guilty of sexual offences against her on Thursday, Young, 49, stated: “No one should be able to give consent on another’s behalf.” Her daughter, Alex Young, also urged a legal amendment clarifying that third‑party consent cannot be invoked in court.
Barristers and campaigners argued that no statute recognises third‑party consent as a valid defence, and they called for a public debate and greater education on consent.
Kate Parker, a criminal barrister and founder of the Schools Consent Project, said: “The law contains no provision allowing a person to rely on another’s statement that they believed consent existed. You cannot effectively delegate consent to a third party; the legislation has never recognised that, and the Sexual Offences Act 2003 makes no such allowance.”
In this case and similar ones, defence counsel are invoking a defence that the defendant honestly and reasonably believed the victim was consenting.
The trial heard that the four men, strangers to each other, failed to obtain Joanne Young’s consent before engaging in sexual activity. They claimed they had been misled by Philip Young and mistakenly believed she was consenting.
Parker said it is appropriate for a defendant to describe their state of mind at the time of the alleged offence.
I believe this principle is a cornerstone of our legal system. I hope that as public awareness of consent laws grows, these arguments will lose credibility with juries.
I hope that over time juries and the public become more knowledgeable about consent law, preventing anyone from claiming they were legally safe because a third party told them to act.
Harriet Wistrich, a solicitor and director of the Centre for Women’s Justice, said the jury in the Young case ultimately rejected the defence.
She said it should be clear in law that a person cannot consent on someone else’s behalf, though she noted that this could be explicitly codified.
Defence barristers should vigorously represent their clients, as is their duty, but they must avoid overstepping by relying on myths or stereotypes.
Ciara Bergman, chief executive of Rape Crisis England & Wales, agreed that consent law should be examined. The Sexual Offences Act 2003 states: “A person consents if they agree by choice and have the freedom and capacity to make that choice.”
She said we need to strengthen existing laws, but the real issue lies in our understanding of consent.
She said the law is already clear, but its interpretation and application are frequently flawed. Misunderstandings arise among defendants, barristers, and juries, showing that consent is specific, ongoing, and dependent on the circumstances. An unconscious person cannot consent.
Another aspect is that drugging a person is the opposite of consent. These organized drug‑facilitated sexual abuse cases are increasingly revealing a disturbing attraction some people have toward women who cannot consent.
Professor Miranda Horvath, director of the Institute for Social Justice and Crime at the University of Suffolk, said that incorrect beliefs about consent must be robustly challenged.
She emphasized that it is vital for people to understand that legally no one can give consent on another’s behalf, highlighting the need for clear education on consent for all ages.
She said rape and serious sexual offences are deliberate choices made by perpetrators, and a lack of understanding about a partner’s consent cannot be an acceptable excuse.
Labour MP Jess Phillips said the government should review whether the law needs tightening, adding: “It is right that the government strength‑tests whether the law can unequivocally state that consent cannot be given by a third party, and we must be satisfied it does.”
She added that although the law says consent cannot be given by a third party, it is still being used as a defence. Tightening the law might have forced the men to plead guilty, sparing Joanne Young a trial.
A Ministry of Justice spokesperson said: “The law is clear: no one can consent on another’s behalf. Consent must be given personally, with the freedom and capacity to choose. We keep criminal law under review and will continue to explore ways to better protect victims.”
Also Read
- Strategic Foresight: How AI Helps Entrepreneurs Cut Through the Productivity Illusion
- The Arrival of Godlike AI Is Inevitable, Regardless of Our Pace
- Pakistan and Sweden Launch Bilateral Investment Treaty Modernization
- Early Polar Vortex Disruption Threatens a Colder European Winter — Can Heat Pumps Keep Energy Bills in Check?


